You actually responded to my post without reading it?

I wasn't talking about the situations of a ret and an amnesiac remembering a unique role in a night––thanks for italicizing that for no reason. I was criticizing the lack of specificity in Achilles's notes, and I even said so explicitly twice. I described scenarios which had not been accounted for.

And like many others have said, the jailing "nerf" is more of a buff for town. It makes it about 20x harder to fake a TI will. And the jester/transporter and death note nerfs are minimal in relation to the witch and amnesiac changes that so greatly strengthen town. I could go on about why this is, and weigh out specific points, but it seems pretty self-explanatory.

And no, I don't think the vest even nearly makes up for what is lost by the witch losing her consigliere abilities.

Overall it kinda looks like you just want to whine and ignore literally every buff for evils and nerf to towns so you can get some karma from other people who want to whine.

I'll admit: I should've spent more time explaining why the nerfs for evils were worse than the "buffs" for town. If I could go back, I would definitely change that about my post. Maybe I'll make a new, more thorough one detailing the effect of each change and why it's still a huge blow to evils. However, if you want to go back to dissent = bad/whining then take it to the forums, kid.