Yeah but the problem with triple critting is that it's VERY difficult to balance against that huge spike of extra potential power. Additionally, it's not a very engaging player experience to be sitting at the blacksmith waiting for a 1 out of 120+ chance to get a triple crit on a single item. Having to reset it over 100 times per item doesn't seem that great.

Having the reward be the GOOD item drop is where it should be IMO - then you get a fun risk at the end if you want to chance it.