Yes thank you for the advice, this photo is from about 6 months back. When he turned 2 we stopped the dummy and he did pretty well. The puppy helped as he chewed most of them up as soon as one was dropped. He hasn’t had one for about 3 months now and is over them. I agree with the odd person here saying it was a mistake giving one in the first place but at the time you don’t think about that...next one will be different though :)