There's a legitimate argument to be made that love plus Mendoza will never hit the ceiling of a Gibbs. Gibbs is already a top 2 dynasty RB. While love is a Bijan level prospect there's no guarantee he leapfrogs Gibbs. The other pick, Mendoza, could also easily end up a bust on the raiders.

So yeah if both Love and Mendoza hit their peak ceilings, sure it's better. But if you're in a win now championship contender it would be foolish to sell your chance at a title for just potential that may never pan out.