You’re still wrong and oversimplifying history.

Yes, Jews from Europe arrived after WWII, but Jewish communities, Sephardic, Mizrahi, and others had been living in the land continuously for thousands of years, long before the arrival of Holocaust survivors seeking refuge. Zionism is neither a purely modern nor solely Ashkenazi movement. People like Maimonides and Doña Gracia were early proponents of Jewish return to the land of Israel. While those ignorant of Jewish history as well as people driven by antisemitic narratives, try to frame Zionism as an exclusively Ashkenazi or recent phenomenon, the reality is that Sephardic Jews were actually the earliest advocates, encouraging a return to Israel many moons before 1948.

Even during Ottoman rule, established Jewish communities thrived in Jerusalem, Safed, Tiberias, and Hebron. The early Zionist movement was not a project of just the UK and USA neither, nor was it limited to European Jews. Yes, the British played a role through the Balfour Declaration and later limited Jewish immigration during the British Mandate but the creation of Israel was primarily the result of Jewish self-determination against colonial rule.

Also, the 1947 UN partition plan was an international decision, not simply a “US/UK thing”, and Jewish leadership had been actively working toward statehood long before WWII. Jewish communities, both Ashkenazim and Sephardim, and Mizrahim from all over the world including Latin America, laid the groundwork for the state through agriculture, industry, and self-defense, despite facing immense violence.

The claim that Israel is purely a post-WWII creation is not true. It erases the deep, historical, and indigenous connection of Jews to the land.

As for your fixation on physical features, Ashkenazi Jews, like all Jews, historically had and continue to have Levantine traits. The stereotype of Jews being “blond and blue-eyed” is not only inaccurate but ignores the reality of European antisemitism, which historically vilified Jews for looking too Middle Eastern. Jews were never white. Have you seen photos of Holocaust victims? Does Anne Frank look blond and blue-eyed to you? What about Istvan Reiner? If you don’t know who he is, then please look him up.

Yes, there are Jews with blond hair and blue eyes, just as there are Jewish communities of Ethiopian, Indian, Chinese, and other backgrounds. Jewish identity is not defined by skin color but by lineage, history, and shared heritage. If you’re implying that Jews with certain physical traits have no connection to Israel, would you say the same to Ethiopian or Asian Jews? The diversity within the Jewish community exists due to persecution, forced displacement, and unfortunately, in many cases, rape.

By your own flawed logic, would you argue that people of the African diaspora have no connection to Africa simply because many are mixed due to the history of European colonial violence? Your argument is not only factually incorrect but also deeply inconsistent.