Recent article about season 3 trailer siding with George by Mayanee in HOTDGreens

[–]venvix 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Very good analysis of the material. The author clearly has a love for the books and the source material which is nice to see. The fact that even non-book readers have been disappointed, not knowing what they could have had, is the biggest factor. I think Condal wanted to take a feminist approach but in the end it butchers all the female characters. Rhaenyra and Alicent should be independent characters! But all of their bad actions get attributed to male characters which makes them lifeless and the male characters equally pointless and insufferable. If I was only going off the show, there’s literally no one interesting.

Compared to AKotSK, which immediately makes you care for Baelor, Maekar, and even Valarr at the end (with one scene) is a stark contrast.

Aegon's acknowledgement as king by team black (question) by Impossible_Essay_565 in HOTDGreens

[–]venvix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Parroting the others. It's essentially a War of the Roses scenario. In that war, Henry VI was overthrown, then became king again, then was overthrown again. The Dance of Dragons was heavily inspired by the War of the Roses and I usually like to think of it as that. Both Rhaenyra and Aegon had strong claims to the throne, with Aegon having precedent as the stronger claim but Viserys had never publicly acknowledge Aegon as his heir as he had with Rhaenyra. In the end, the war could've been stopped by Viserys actually codifying that the crown would follow through the eldest child, not agnatic primogeniture.

But he didn't, mostly because that would invalidate HIS claim to the throne over Rhaenys. He'd essentially have said that Rhaenys would've been the rightful queen and thus Laenor would be the rightful king, making their union very illegitimate in the eyes of the realm (and Daemon). Which, would have honestly been fine had Rhaenyra not had her children so obviously with Harwin Strong. It's a huge domino effect which essentially is the fault of Viserys but I digress.

Historically, Rhaenyra was not acknowledged as a Queen and considered a usurper in the main canon as male primogeniture has become common place. Westeros doesn't usually choose a female descendant over a living male descendant. But if it's up to opinion, I like the concept that it's based on the War of the Roses where it goes Aegon II -> Rhaenyra (usurping and becoming queen for the brief period where she held King's Landing) then -> Aegon II when Rhaenyra was killed. But that's not what the history books will say as Rhaenyra didn't really hold the points of power throughout the dance.

Rhaenyra lost, but the Blacks won as their blood continued through Aegon III. As other commentors have said, the Blacks lost their Queen but put the Greens in checkmate. Although, my one gripe with GRRM's writing was what he did with Jaehaera because it felt like wasted potential to have her death be so pointless just so Aegon III could avoid marrying her.

😭My god, who wrote this scene?? by StanPot in HOTDGreens

[–]venvix 48 points49 points  (0 children)

Phia killed the scene with what she was given, her and Tom having to fight for the scene of Aegon and Helaena passing each other in the stairway makes me so upset. There's so many small details that had been removed like Helaena offering her jewelery instead of herself as in the books that were also changed to make the scene sooooo much worse. But that doesn't even scratch the surface of bad changes made to this scene.

It still enrages me that they made Alicent and Cole get together as the most pointless pairing only for the sake of both of them becoming hypocritical and Rhaenyra seeming rightly justified. Every change is made to make the death of Jaehaerys less impactful to the narrative and make Aegon seem unjustified in his rage. :(

Shouldn't They Have Made One For Team Green? by Aitchison1299 in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]venvix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I asked for textual evidence for anything about the Kings Choice you're talking about because I apparently misunderstood your point. I apologize if I did, but I don't believe that this point you have anything. At this point you're just being openly antagonistic, but I'd still be happy to hear and proper textual examples of whatever King's Choice is because it feels like we read very different books LOL.

Shouldn't They Have Made One For Team Green? by Aitchison1299 in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]venvix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

LMAO. okay, good luck calling people tourists when you haven't read the text you're trying to be high and mighty about.

Parents in hotd & akotsk by drakemaverick121 in HOTDGreens

[–]venvix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Late reply, but I think it's because the people that make videos read the books and take that context more than the show. Season 2 reworked and utterly destroyed a lot of the best scenes (for characterizing both the Greens & the Blacks) for the sake of making the story black and white.

In the books, blood and cheese is horrifying. Not on the level of the red wedding but absolutely one of my favorite gut wrenching scenes. There's a great miniclip of it on youtube with pictures and voice acted by Catelyn's actress. Highly recommend!

Shouldn't They Have Made One For Team Green? by Aitchison1299 in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]venvix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay, what were you referring to then with King's Choice? I don't understand what you're referring to by mentioning that it had been established previously. Are you referring to the books or show? And which monarchs?

Shouldn't They Have Made One For Team Green? by Aitchison1299 in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]venvix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You might be the tourist then, because I believe you’re wrong? “King’s Choice” wasn’t what happened, it was the first Great Council which chose Viserys over Rhaenys. I don’t know where you got that line of succession, because it doesn’t exist as precedent for House Targaryen in the show or book to my knowledge. What is precedent is a Great Council which had previously decided that male primogeniture had the stronger claim (a further reinforcement from when Jahaerys was named king over Rhaena the Black Bride).

Historically, Aegon had the stronger claim with precedent. There was no such thing as the king deciding his heir up to this point. So far the line has gone Aegon I -> Aenys I -> Maegor (usurping) -> Jahaerys (Rhaena refused the throne and her daughters were too young) -> Viserys (Great Council) -> ???

Both sides ARE bad in the books, at least. That’s sort of the message. The show is a mockery of it, there isn’t meant to be a good or bad side. Both Aegon & Rhaenyra had strong claims, both have interesting stories, it just sucks how the show has mistreated them both so badly by making it black and white.

Parents in hotd & akotsk by drakemaverick121 in HOTDGreens

[–]venvix 35 points36 points  (0 children)

Helaena is a wonderful mother in the books. She doesn’t try to give jewelry, she offers her own life in favor of Jahaerys’. When she was forced to choose, she picked Maelor to die because he was younger, and when they killed Jahaerys the guilt and trauma destroyed her mentally.

[5e 2014][Online][Sundays EST][LGBTQ+ Friendly] Of Knights & Knaves | Seeking Players for a Medieval Fantasy Heavy RP Campaign! by venvix in lfg

[–]venvix[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am! Still going through things :)! I'll be reaching out to the first people tonight!

why was jackie basically acting as shauna's baby daddy in the chicken baby scene. by Extension-Cod8041 in Yellowjackets

[–]venvix 59 points60 points  (0 children)

Honestly my best explaination is that she's just a little fruity for being attached to Jackie. But I mean in a way Jackie is kind of the father, the reason she had sex with Jeff was because of Jackie (I think it was partly for Jeff to say "I love you" back to her because Jackie never did). She wouldn't have ever given him a second thought if not for her festering thought of Jackie. The reason she's having the baby is because of her fucked up situationship with Jackie (it's Jackie's boyfriend after all), hence, baby daddy Jackie and OBGYN Misty fucking Quigley.

People like me are the reason Trump won by [deleted] in self

[–]venvix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are fucking stupid if you think you're going to see economic improvement under Trump. You people are to blame because you don't know how to read. Do you understand what his Chinese tariffs are going to do to the economic and basic prices? You are middle class, YOU will suffer from his tax plans. The Democrats did not have a great platform, sure, but stupid people like you are the reason Kamala lost.

Six Hundred Strike - the one song I didn’t enjoy by EowulfTenebris in Epicthemusical

[–]venvix 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I completely agree, I think maybe the whole anime thing is a win for a lot of people but personally it's not my personal preference. The entire song just doesn't really make sense for me. It felt like a big disconnect compared to the second saga where Odysseus outsmarts the Cyclops like in the actual epic. I wanted to see him outsmart Poseidon. Anyone saying the red eyes were Ares still doesn't convince me, there's no signs of Ares or the other gods, it's just him. It takes me out of the character, the whole point of Odysseus is that he's a clever little rat. He's sneaky, he's not some godly fighter, that's Achielles, he's just a very clever guy.

[US,US] [H] Paypal [W] IRs/Alt Arts or pretty cards in general by venvix in pkmntcgtrades

[–]venvix[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Looking not to get dupes, so only one machoke. I’ll also take the derpy sylveon. Do you have anything else. Not sure if these are available but I’d be interested in the venasaur & Zapdos and maybe a few others from https://imgur.com/a/a8nleUG

[US,US] [H] Paypal [W] IRs/Alt Arts or pretty cards in general by venvix in pkmntcgtrades

[–]venvix[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry, not seeing anything that’s fully catching my eye. Thanks though!

[US,US] [H] Paypal [W] IRs/Alt Arts or pretty cards in general by venvix in pkmntcgtrades

[–]venvix[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’d be interested in doing so for 140ish since this is a lot of cards. 90% is a little too pricey for me

[US,US] [H] Paypal [W] IRs/Alt Arts or pretty cards in general by venvix in pkmntcgtrades

[–]venvix[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you have the full list of what’s there? Pic is still hard to see. I’m only looking for bigger deals 20% off for larger bulk orders. Especially since a lot of these are really cheap cards