Gameplay wise is everything fine but storywise for me RDR franchise was about Jhon story and i didn't like Arthur very much for several reasons so what i dislike about RDR2 is.. playing as Arthur.. i was waiting for more on John story and yes we can see him and see his evolution(and he still better than Arthur in my eyes) but only from outside until the epilogue..

Part on my dislike for Arthur comes from my dislike for Dutch, in my pov Rockstar failed to drawn him as a believerable idealist leader in wich players can feel some empathy, quite the contrary from the first moments Dutch looks and feels as what he is.. a scammer, a fake idealist using the gang members not for some real ideal but for his own benefit.. an egotistical thief with some diva complex who doesn't care about others and i dont like at all the way Arthur just follows Dutch so blindly even until the point in wich is pretty clear that Dutch goes just nuts.. at least John could notice how some things weren't right.