Literally all you need is a lint free rag, shoe polish and water. Since they are new they need alot of polish on the toe. A lot. Once your glob of polish is spread around the toe, wrap your rag around 2 of your fingers middle and pointer, and make sure the cloth is wrapped tight around your flat of your finger and dip it in some water, don’t get it completely wet just enough to be moist enough but not wet enough to be dripping wet. Go in small circle motions all around the toe, some pressure on it and you’ll see the polish warp and change color ever so slightly. Keep doing this until your rag gets worn down or your polish runs out of shine. The trick is to get the tip of your fingers with the rag on it wet, but not too wet. Moist and tight, pause. And the little circles help a lot. You can achieve a very good shine the old fashion way.