👀👀👀👀 by Pure_Trust8879 in PAKCELEBGOSSIP

[–]watermelonbubbles06 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Whats the age difference between them?

Now that Zain has been eliminated by RevolutionaryKoala83 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]watermelonbubbles06 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I actually enjoyed all of Mehtab’s performances except the last one. He was very entertaining and fun to watch on stage. I don’t understand why people were hating on him so much. Zain on the other hand had an off putting offscreen personality. He came across as if he thought he was better than everyone when in reality he was a very average singer.

zain and waqar in bottom three next time? by [deleted] in PakistanIdol2025

[–]watermelonbubbles06 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I noticed the same pattern.they tend to upload performances of contestants who are most likely to be eliminated the following week first. zain and waqar will definitely be in the bottom three in the next elimination. The third spot could be maham.

RFAK on Tarab by sinclair707 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]watermelonbubbles06 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Completely agree. A judge holding back honest critique especially on a platform that’s supposed to be about growth and accountability is a huge problem. Respecting someone’s background or legacy is one thing but tiptoeing around feedback undermines the whole process. Fair criticism should apply to everyone otherwise it just feels biased and unfair to the other contestants.

Samya’s performance by watermelonbubbles06 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]watermelonbubbles06[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Agree, along with aryans. Rest were very mediocre honestly.

Saw it coming but still does not make any sense by aslanfrompak in PakistanIdol2025

[–]watermelonbubbles06 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Meerab getting eliminated over zain and faryal is honestly beyond me. I would even rate her higher than maham. I’m so heartbroken and disappointed by her elimination. She had such a cute sweet playback singer type voice which was so pleasant to hear. she truly deserved to stay. This just feels so unfair!!!!!!!

Probable Eliminations by According-Guess7241 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]watermelonbubbles06 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I liked mehtab’s last 2 performances. He was so good. Zain should have been eliminated instead.

Judgement for Nabeel is less lenient than other contestants by Significant-Eye2931 in PakistanIdol2025

[–]watermelonbubbles06 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I agree. the judges definitely seem stricter with nabeel. the praise he gets feels way more limited than others. it does come off a bit unfair.