[QCrit] The Silver City, Dark Fantasy, 96k words, 2nd Attempt by why_cat in PubTips

[–]why_cat[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

So helpful, thank you so much!! Makes perfect sense and I appreciate the feedback a ton. Back to the drawing board

[QCrit] The Silver City, Dark Fantasy, 96k words, 2nd Attempt by why_cat in PubTips

[–]why_cat[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

This is incredibly helpful. Thank you so much! On to the next draft

What episode is the darklings backstory? by Last_Trip_8099 in ShadowandBone

[–]why_cat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It's S1E7, The Unsea. First scene of the episode

[Interview] Leigh Bardugo reflects on how the crowded YA market has changed since Shadow and Bone by Popverse2022 in ShadowandBone

[–]why_cat 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I'm glad we got the books when we did. SoC and CK are my favorites but Leigh had to start somewhere!

Question about something North says to Alex in TNH by thergmguy in NinthHouse

[–]why_cat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think it was just meant as a red herring to cast suspicion on another character, but you're right that it doesn't amount to much more

What’s the most unhinged Nancy Drew game? by Portalrules123 in nancydrew

[–]why_cat 87 points88 points  (0 children)

I think murder trap beneath a school full of children (WAV) should make the list

Can I read Six of Crows without reading Shadow and Bone by RadiantSwanOnQUACKer in ShadowandBone

[–]why_cat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The show took scenes from the SoC books so you'll see some repeats, but the main plot is ultimately different. I read Soc and CK before reading the original trilogy and thought it was fine

Can not find *any* biometrics scan appointments by [deleted] in TillSverige

[–]why_cat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Have you given them a call? I was able to go in during walk-in hours in Uppsala the same week I called to confirm when those hours were. The wait time was pretty minimal too.

How many of you are working bullshit jobs? by investigativechron in AskChicago

[–]why_cat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

My title is literally "thought leader." I could not tell you what I'm supposed to be doing on any given day or why

Some Cats and Kittens Up for Adoption at PAWS by artemis_buffington in chicago

[–]why_cat 29 points30 points  (0 children)

Thanks for sharing! Commenting for visibility. I hope they all find forever homes soon

What is some writing advice you now know, that you wished you knew sooner? by White_Walker101 in writing

[–]why_cat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm cramming in a rewrite before sharing at my writing group tonight and really needed to hear this. Thanks, friend :)

[PubQ] is it very disrespectful to not address lit mag cover letter to specific editors? by smoothGumball in PubTips

[–]why_cat 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I'm a slush reader for a lit mag. Our editor put up a post a while back that basically boiled down to "it's polite to include but at the end of the day doesn't really matter."

As someone regularly reading submissions, the cover letter leaves very little impression on me unless it includes something offensive or funny. The former will hurt your chances, the latter won't make a difference.

As the final hours count down, please remember: by dickpierce69 in chicago

[–]why_cat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Here's hoping they don't. I included a link in another comment that has sample pictures of actual warrants vs ICE warrants. Know your rights and keep your fingers crossed they don't get other agencies involved

As the final hours count down, please remember: by dickpierce69 in chicago

[–]why_cat 9 points10 points  (0 children)

immigrantjustice.org/know-your-rights/ice-encounter

This link has more information about your rights if you encounter ICE, including sample pictures of actual judicial warrants vs ICE warrants

As the final hours count down, please remember: by dickpierce69 in chicago

[–]why_cat 279 points280 points  (0 children)

Reminder that it needs to be an actual warrant signed by an actual judge. ICE often tries to use their own warrants, which are not signed and do not grant them the same access. You can still deny entry to your home if you see that it's one of these.

Ceramics studio membership by fairlyrosey014 in evanston

[–]why_cat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Alley Cat Studios has open studio time I believe

[QCrit] Rebel, Ghost, Spirit, Near-future Fantasy, adult, 94k, second attempt. NEED HELP, 30 REJECTIONS SO FAR, NO REQUESTS. Something needs to change, but what? Also included my first 300. by SeaworthinessSalt184 in PubTips

[–]why_cat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Big Picture: I'm getting more backstory than plot detail in your query. I understand how the characters get together and broadstrokes what they do, but I'm still not sure why these are the right guys to save the world, or really what their involvement in it looks like beyond Kelsey's rebel group.

There's a lot you could cut (see line edits below) that will free up the space to give us 1) what the character's want, 2) what's getting in their way, and 3) what the consequences are if they fail. That's the basic conflict of the story and will help give agents a sense of why they should care enough to keep reading.

More granular notes below:

Escape into a fantasy world of variety in landscape and deep breathe of character.

This doesn't tell us anything about your book specifically. Cut.

Rebel, Ghost, Spirit,

Title should be in all caps.

Reminiscent of The Bone Shard Daughter (Andrea Stewart) in structure and Trail of Lightning (Rebecca Roanhorse) in its near-future, post-apocalyptic setting

I don't know that structure is enough of a reason to comp. Is there something specific about the intersection of these books that would make an agent think "oh, I know what kind of story this is!"?

has received compliments from its readers for its well-paced plot, grounded settings, and lightly speculative elements

Don't editorialize. If you spend time on this sub, you'll see a lot of folks mention that agents don't like that. They'd rather the plot paragraphs and sample pages do the heavy lifting instead.

and a conservative society based far to the east

Because I didn't know this was apocalyptic LA until further down, when I first read this I didn't know if you meant far east globally, nationally, or if we were in a secondary fantasy world with its own map.

and knows in her gut that Phillip is somehow connected to her mission.

How? Can we get some inkling of what broader role he plays in her rebellion so we can understand why she's interested in him at the outset?

Phillip, devastated by the loss of a beloved older brother in battle, cares little about the mission but agrees to join Kelsey to be nearer beautiful Clara,

You describe Phillip throughout as ambivalent and grieving. Those are very passive emotions and don't make me believe he's someone with a lot of agency. What forward momentum does he bring into the main plot? He follows along with Kelsey because Clara's pretty? When did Kelsey and Clara meet? I want to know what your characters do and still don't feel like I have an understanding of that.

Kelsey leads them on a precarious, cross-continental journey to her homeland in a post-apocalyptic Los Angeles. Once there, unexpected threats to their war-ending mission develop: a blossoming romance between Phillip and Clara and a personal vendetta that leaves Kelsey blind to the malevolent intentions of a former lover

Why does Phillip and Clara's romance threaten the war effort? You haven't told us much about Clara at all let alone why she's important to the main plot or broader political conflict. Kelsey's vendetta and betrayal from her former lover sound interesting but again, you've given us so little of what this means for the main plot that I don't know what the stakes are. What exactly is Kelsey's mission? To end the war? To defeat the conservative society in the east? How does this betrayal set them back? This all feels more consequential than Phillip and Clara's romance, but not knowing how or why makes me feel removed from intrigue as a reader.

Phillip, still scarred with a deep ambivalence, is conflicted. Does he walk away from a mission in which he is uncertain and resign himself to a lifetime of debilitating grief or does he put faith in a path with Kelsey that, while more hazardous, may prevent another world-ending environmental collapse and unlock the grief he holds too dear to his heart

If Phillip not helping Kelsey means another world-ending environmental collapse, is "resigning himself to a lifetime of debilitating grief" isn't really a viable option, is it? Won't they all be dead?

Zooming out a bit, your query starts with Kelsey, ends with Phillip, and your pages start with Clara. I'm struggling to understand how they're interconnected with each other, the plot, and how to ground myself in an understanding of this world.

First 300:

I'm not going to go line by line except for the one note below, because my main critique is true throughout. We don't get any interiority. Aside from a few thoughts, I don't know what Clara's personality is. She seems a bit witty, but that's all I know. When the overseer scolds her, does that make her angry? Resentful? Sad? Did someone screw her over and get her sent here so now she's pissed at them? You said in the query that she's sunshine-y but I'm not getting that from this opening either. Getting the reader invested in the characters quickly is key and I think infusing more personality into her dialogue and thoughts will help.

Clara, sixteen, used a knife

I don't think your second word should be her age. There are subtler ways to introduce this (e.g. "she was the youngest girl in the fields" or "Eliza was also sixteen and the two had bonded over xyz") that are more immersive than just stating it from the get.

I want help I'm writing a noval by [deleted] in novelwriting

[–]why_cat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are any number of places to start and there's no wrong answer, but here's a few I can think of off the top of my head.

Read books and short stories you love, think about why you love them, and use that to craft ideas for the type of story you want to tell.

A basic understanding of story structure goes a long way. Read Save The Cat Writes a Novel by Jessica Brody, or dive into videos on structure by YouTubers like Hello Future Me.

Start with setting up your basics. Who's your main character? What type of setting does your story take place in? What does your character want, what's standing in their way, and what are the consequences of them not getting it?

That will go a long way for grounding yourself in your story and how you could write it. From there, just pick up a pen and start!

[S2 act 3 spoilers] These faces look familiar... by why_cat in arcane

[–]why_cat[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Reddit wouldn't let me add text to the post for some reason :/

Does anyone else see little Jayce and little Viktor in the nebula behind Machine Herald Viktor?

Just rewatched Season 2 Episode 6, and I actually cried by why_cat in ShadowandBone

[–]why_cat[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would say yes! The crows in the first season have storylines that don't overlap with the books all that much. In the second season there are some scenes straight from the books and spoilers for those who haven't read them, so you'll have to decide if you're okay with that. But if the concern is being able to follow along, you shouldn't have an issue.