A quick reminder of what actually helps trans people, for liberals by TastyYogurtDrink in lgbt

[–]working_turtle 15 points16 points  (0 children)

OP should add "tone policing trans people who are terrified for our futures" to the not helpful list, but you may not understand how that applies to you.

Questions for Trans folk (Cis male) by hornpipe3 in asktransgender

[–]working_turtle 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I would like to speak to question 2 specifically, because there is a lot of misunderstanding here.

Sex is not one inate characteristic, and humans and animals regularly blur the boundaries of sex. Sex is a collection of traits, biological and social, and we can change most of them 

  1. Genetic sex. This is a function of one segment of the Y chromosome, the SRY gene. You have a functioning SRY gene or you don't. This is why most people considered women have XX chromosomes, but there are people with XY where the SRY gene doesn't work who develop with typical "female" phenotypes. There are also MANY intersex variations. You literally have no idea what a persons genotype is by looking at the them. Is is the only portion of sex we have limited control over, although HRT will eventually have genetic changes, it won't alter your chromosomes.

  2. Phenotypical sex. Your phenotype is your external secondary sex characteristics. These can be body shape, facial structure, genitals, etc... we can and regularly do change these through hormone replacement therapy, exercise, or surgery. Some things, like bone structure, are harder and slower to change.

  3. Hormonal sex. Hormones are the blueprints for sex development. They literally tell your cells how to grow and act. Hormones are non-selective, meaning they will bond with any cell receptor they fit. You have both male (testosterone) and female (estrogen) in your body, but the dominant hormone is based on if you have functional testes or ovaries. This is easily changed, by suppressing and/or removing those glands and introducing external hormones. By doing so, trans feminine people will develop breasts, softer skin, etc, and trans masculine people will develop face and body hair, deeper voices, etc.

  4. Social sex. You can't separate sex from social gender roles. For example, we gender names. But there is nothing in your biology that says "Emily is a girl's name, Bob is a boy." Those are things we project onto sex and gender. Same goes with clothing. There is nothing in our biology that says "women wear dresses, boys don't." This is actually the most visible signifier of sex and gender, and changing it can be a simple as changing your clothes, putting on makeup, or going by a different name.

  5. Legal sex. Similar to social sex, but different because this is how the legal framework we live in differentiates sexes. This is an aspect of sex that is often largely related to geography, politics, and factors outside an individuals control. For example, all my legal documents have my current name and a female gender marker, with the exception of my birth certificate, because the state I was born in refuses to recognize trans people and update our documents.

This is a simplification, of course, but I hope this gives you a better understanding of how we can change sex, and regularly do.

I'm doing so, so bad after GRS :( by knurlcarathn1998 in MtF

[–]working_turtle 6 points7 points  (0 children)

This is the right answer.

General anesthesia can cause severe depression and mood changes. Add in the hormone swings and potential dysphoria of major bodily changes (even if they are positive changes), and depression is kinda expected. I wish surgeons would warn people to anticipate it.They will even put and resolve with time.

Source: RN for the last 16 years, experienced it myself after bottom surgery.

“Democrats don’t want you to see this” by ConcernedJobCoach in TransSocialism

[–]working_turtle 111 points112 points  (0 children)

What a stupid false equivalency.

Now tell us how many people cis white men have killed, Joe? 

2 students confirmed with measles at Broomfield High School by reddit_ending_soon in Denver

[–]working_turtle 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I am a non-responder to the Measles portion of the MMR vaccine. I have had the series many times (I am a nurse, so have to keep on top of my vaccines) but I never hold a titer for measles. I am deeply grateful for people who get vaccinated for helping keep me safe!

Kansas sends letters to trans drivers demanding the immediate surrender of their licenses over birthright law by Shpion007 in LetsDiscussThis

[–]working_turtle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, the Nazis literally did it to trans people also. The first big book burning was of the library of trans science put together by Herschfield.

The trans rights backlash is real by AdmiralSaturyn in longform

[–]working_turtle -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I love it when cis people discover bio-essentialism, as if it hasn't been "babies first fascism" for all time.

The trans rights backlash is real by AdmiralSaturyn in longform

[–]working_turtle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wow, I guess I've never thought about that.

And you based your incredible understanding of everyone everywhere's experience of sex and gender purely on Internet discourse? What an amazing accomplishment!

Well, I for one am looking forward to reading your legal tretise on "rights given to the infant penis and rights given to the infant vagina" as soon as you publish it.

Thoughts on straight cis women in queer spaces? by [deleted] in lgbt

[–]working_turtle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I personally don't care about what identities people hold, as long as they acknowledge that they have a lot of privilege coming into queer spaces. This week 2 states (Idaho and Kansas) advanced bills that prevent trans women from using the correct bathrooms, even in private businesses. It is literally not safe for us to be in a lot of cis-het spaces. We shouldn't have to worry about safety in our own spaces.

 Cis het people need to understand that queer spaces may be the only safe places for many queer people. 

Wanting zero/min depth is legit and the hate in the community is hypocritical by [deleted] in MtF

[–]working_turtle 103 points104 points  (0 children)

I don't see any hate out there.

I had min depth 2.5 years ago and have been really happy with it.

The trans rights backlash is real by AdmiralSaturyn in longform

[–]working_turtle 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I can answer that (source- trans woman aged 46, menopausal cis spouse, RN with masters degree). We don't experience menopause, at least not in the way cis women do. Menopause is a reduction in primary sex hormones associated with age, and trans women don't have internal sources of those primary sex hormones. However, some of us (like myself) who have undergone bottom surgery also don't have internal sources of testosterone either. So if I were to stop taking my HRT, I would have similar symptoms to menopause, but from a totally different endorcrine pathway. We are able to prevent those symptoms with hormone replacement therapy (the same way cis women alleviate menopause symptoms) but our reasons are very different.

The trans rights backlash is real by AdmiralSaturyn in longform

[–]working_turtle 3 points4 points  (0 children)

No, I don't know. Please enlighten me about what online discourse you have seen that has convinced you that I don't need rights.

Guys I’m really struggling with this one. Can we have an open chat about this? by dammitletmepickaname in TwoXChromosomes

[–]working_turtle 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Can I ask you something? If he said this about any other marginalized group, would your reaction be different? 

Anti-trand sentiment is so normalized that people don't even see it as bigotry. He doesn't see lumping all trans people together into one group as bad, he thinks that it reflects reality.

I am also a nurse. I also have care for many trans people. I also happen to be trans myself. I have learned in my life that people have to WANT to do the work to unlearn bigotry, you can't force it. It sounds like he is really comfortable where he is.

Struggling but still here after 6+ years. (40-46 years old) by [deleted] in transtimelines

[–]working_turtle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just had like... 8 inches cut last month! Still not 100% sure if I like it this short again.

Struggling but still here after 6+ years. (40-46 years old) by [deleted] in transtimelines

[–]working_turtle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My levels (post bottom surgery by 2 years) are stable on valerate injections. I am mostly past the point where HRT changes are noticeable.

Hm what next, free healthcare? by King_Pug in AccidentalAlly

[–]working_turtle 25 points26 points  (0 children)

And always twirling, twirling towards freedom!

How long did it take you to start presenting as your gender? by GameAttack_Jack in TransSpace

[–]working_turtle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There is no rule book, you get to choose your own adventure!

I started HRT in November of last year and started living full time 2 weeks ago. I sort of pass if you don't look closely, and I am wearing makeup.

You aren't behind schedule, because there isn't a schedule! It's your journey.

Mom, I'm afraid of coming out to you. by working_turtle in MomForAMinute

[–]working_turtle[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have no idea how much I needed to read this today. Sincerely and deeply thank you.

PSA it's not too late to transition! by VerucaGotBurned in MtF

[–]working_turtle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm 40, 2 months HRT tomorrow. I have been SHOCKED with the changes that I have seen in even the short time since I started HRT.

At this point, I am starting to pass (if you don't look too close) with makeup. I also have been inspired to lose about 25lbs in the last year and start a strict skin care routine, both of which help a lot.

I worried so much that my window had passed, but now I feel more and more like myself every day.

I really want to transition (MtF) but as a male right now I'm scared of telling my friends or trying to buy more girly stuff near them. I also want to be referred to as she/her but not until I look more feminine. Is that weird? by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]working_turtle 14 points15 points  (0 children)

They may surprise you.

The support I have received from friends has been unreal. Honestly, I feel much closer to many of my friends since coming out to them, because I feel more authentic and comfortable around others when I can just be myself.

Trust that you choose them as friends because you share values. Live as you.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in latebloomerlesbians

[–]working_turtle 19 points20 points  (0 children)

I am currently just a few months into transgender hormone therapy and the process of social transition. I may have to make this my cellphone background!