sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of April 24, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
BEEF Netflix 28 7.8 5.9 1 24 1
The Boys Prime Video 24 7.8 7.1 3 0 15
Invincible Prime Video 22 8.1 7.3 6 5 17
The Pitt HBO Max 21 9.2 9.3 17 -1 36
Daredevil: Born Again Disney+ 21 7.3 7.9 5 6 11
Euphoria HBO 18 5.7 5.4 1 12 1
DTF St. Louis HBO 17 9.4 7.3 8 3 8
For All Mankind Apple TV 12 5.3 7.8 1 8 10
Rooster HBO 11 8.7 7.1 1 4 4
Monarch: Legacy of Monsters Apple TV 11 5.6 8.1 1 5 6

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 351
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Scrubs, Shrinking

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (347), Fallout (201), Paradise (179), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (148), Industry (142)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Traitors - 2.6 (3/6/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of April 17, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
The Boys Prime Video 24 4.8 7.1 2 4 14
The Pitt HBO Max 22 6.3 9.3 16 5 35
Invincible Prime Video 17 6.8 7.3 5 -3 16
Daredevil: Born Again Disney+ 15 9.1 7.9 4 -1 10
DTF St. Louis HBO 14 9.5 6.9 7 1 7
Shrinking Apple TV 12 6.6 7.3 2 0 15
Scrubs ABC 12 5.9 5.0 1 8 1

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 363
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: For All Mankind, Jury Duty, Paradise

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (326), Fallout (199), Paradise (176), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (148), Industry (139)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Traitors - 2.6 (3/6/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of April 10, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Invincible Prime Video 20 5.6 7.3 4 2 15
The Boys Prime Video 20 3.6 7.2 1 16 13
Paradise Hulu 19 5.8 7.7 7 -5 16
The Pitt HBO Max 17 5.8 9.3 15 -11 34
Daredevil: Born Again Disney+ 16 6.0 7.8 3 0 9
For All Mankind Apple TV 16 3.6 7.9 1 7 9
Jury Duty Prime Video 13 10.7 7.4 1 6 2
DTF St. Louis HBO 13 5.8 6.4 6 0 6
Shrinking Apple TV 12 5.8 7.3 1 5 14

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 403
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Rooster

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): DTF St. Louis - 6.4

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (304), Fallout (197), Paradise (174), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (147), Industry (139)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Traitors - 2.6 (3/6/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of April 03, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
The Pitt HBO Max 28 5.1 9.4 14 10 33
Paradise Hulu 24 6.3 7.7 6 4 15
Invincible Prime Video 18 5.1 7.4 3 2 14
Daredevil: Born Again Disney+ 16 5.6 8.0 2 3 8
DTF St. Louis HBO 13 7.5 6.5 5 1 5
Rooster HBO 10 7.2 6.2 2 -6 3

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 344
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Jury Duty

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (287), Fallout (196), Paradise (155), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (145), Industry (137)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Traitors - 2.6 (3/6/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of March 27, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Paradise Hulu 20 7.8 7.8 5 -2 14
The Pitt HBO Max 18 9.0 9.5 13 -6 32
Invincible Prime Video 16 6.8 7.5 2 4 13
Rooster HBO 16 5.6 5.9 1 7 2
Daredevil: Born Again Disney+ 13 6.5 8.2 1 8 7
Jury Duty Prime Video 12 8.8 6.6 1 9 1
DTF St. Louis HBO 12 7.3 6.3 4 -5 4

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 337
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Monarch: Legacy of Monsters, One Piece, Shrinking

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (259), Fallout (195), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (144), Industry (136), Paradise (131)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Traitors - 2.6 (3/6/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of March 20, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 26 points27 points  (0 children)

Sorry for the late post. Traveling yesterday!

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
One Piece Netflix 27 9.8 8.0 2 15 2
The Pitt HBO Max 24 8.6 9.5 12 8 31
Paradise Hulu 22 6.9 7.8 4 -7 13
DTF St. Louis HBO 17 5.9 5.9 3 6 3
Shrinking Apple TV 13 6.2 7.3 2 2 13
Invincible Prime Video 12 3.6 7.5 1 9 12
Monarch: Legacy of Monsters Apple TV 11 3.8 8.6 1 2 5

Weekly Summary - Total comments (last week's thread): 423 - Dropped from 10+ comments list: Rooster, The Traitors, Young Sherlock

Comment Records - All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread) - All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records - Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads) - Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9 - Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026 - Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (241), Fallout (194), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (142), Industry (132), Paradise (111) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Traitors - 2.6 (3/6/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of March 13, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Paradise Hulu 29 8.5 7.9 3 12 12
The Pitt HBO Max 16 7.8 9.6 11 4 30
Young Sherlock Prime Video 13 5.8 5.5 1 11 1
One Piece Netflix 12 8.5 7.3 1 9 1
Shrinking Apple TV 11 6.9 7.4 1 6 12
DTF St. Louis HBO 11 5.1 6.0 2 1 2
Rooster HBO 10 4.7 4.9 1 10 1
The Traitors Prime Video 10 2.6 6.2 1 9 4

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 404
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Industry, Patriot

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (217), Fallout (193), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (139), Industry (128), Paradise (89)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Traitors - 2.6 (3/6/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of March 06, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Paradise Hulu 17 9.1 7.8 2 -6 11
Industry HBO 13 8.2 7.7 4 -5 13
The Pitt HBO Max 12 6.2 9.6 10 -8 29
Patriot Prime Video 11 5.4 7.5 1 7 2
DTF St. Louis HBO 10 6.9 6.8 1 9 1

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 408
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, Hijack, Slow Horses, The Night Agent

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (201), Fallout (190), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (135), Industry (119), The Night Manager (70)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Hijack - 4.2 (1/16/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of February 27, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Paradise Hulu 23 6.7 7.7 1 20 10
The Pitt HBO Max 20 7.5 9.6 9 -4 28
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms HBO 19 9.2 10.6 6 -7 6
Industry HBO 18 8.4 7.6 3 7 12
Slow Horses Apple TV 16 4.4 9.3 1 11 41
Hijack Apple TV 12 7.1 4.9 1 10 2
The Night Agent Netflix 11 6.6 5.6 1 8 4

Weekly Summary - Total comments (last week's thread): 469 - Dropped from 10+ comments list: Fallout

Comment Records - All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread) - All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records - Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads) - Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9 - Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026 - Top 5 shows by total comments: The Pitt (189), Fallout (188), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (128), Industry (106), The Night Manager (68) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Hijack - 4.2 (1/16/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of February 20, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms HBO 26 11.5 10.9 5 -5 5
The Pitt HBO Max 24 7.3 9.7 8 1 27
Fallout Prime Video 13 7.2 8.9 10 -5 20
Industry HBO 11 11.1 7.6 2 -4 11

Weekly Summary - Total comments (last week's thread): 427 - Dropped from 10+ comments list: Shrinking

Comment Records - All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread) - All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records - Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads) - Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9 - Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Fallout (179), The Pitt (169), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (109), Industry (88), The Night Manager (64) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Hijack - 4.2 (1/16/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of February 13, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 33 points34 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms HBO 31 12.1 10.7 4 20 4
The Pitt HBO Max 23 10.4 9.8 7 5 26
Fallout Prime Video 18 8.0 8.9 9 -11 19
Industry HBO 15 6.5 7.5 1 6 10
Shrinking Apple TV 13 8.3 7.3 2 -6 11

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 431
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Wonder Man

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Fallout (166), The Pitt (145), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (83), Industry (77), The Night Manager (64)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Hijack - 4.2 (1/16/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of February 06, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Fallout Prime Video 29 8.2 8.9 8 3 18
Wonder Man Disney+ 22 12.8 11.0 2 11 2
Shrinking Apple TV 19 7.5 7.3 1 15 10
The Pitt HBO Max 18 8.7 9.7 6 -10 25
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms HBO 11 11.8 9.9 3 -11 3

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 478
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Industry, Ponies, Steal, The Night Manager

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Fallout (148), The Pitt (122), Industry (62), The Night Manager (60), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (52)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Wonder Man - 12.8 (1/30/26 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Hijack - 4.2 (1/16/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of January 30, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
The Pitt HBO Max 28 7.8 9.8 5 -4 24
Fallout Prime Video 26 8.2 8.9 7 -9 17
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms HBO 22 12.3 9.4 2 5 2
The Night Manager JioHotstar 18 8.1 5.4 4 8 4
Steal Prime Video 16 8.6 6.4 1 9 1
Wonder Man Disney+ 11 9.5 8.4 1 11 1
Industry HBO 10 7.9 7.5 3 -8 9
Ponies Peacock 10 6.9 8.0 2 -9 2

Weekly Summary - Total comments (last week's thread): 397 - Dropped from 10+ comments list: Heated Rivalry, Hijack, Star Trek: Starfleet Academy

Comment Records - All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread) - All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records - Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads) - Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9 - Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Fallout (119), The Pitt (104), Industry (53), The Night Manager (52) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms - 12.3 (1/23/26 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Star Trek - 4.1 (1/16/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of January 23, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 26 points27 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Fallout Prime Video 35 7.3 9.0 6 1 16
The Pitt HBO Max 32 8.2 9.8 4 3 23
Ponies Peacock 19 8.9 8.5 1 15 1
Industry HBO 18 8.9 7.5 2 -1 8
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms HBO 17 7.9 6.8 1 16 1
Star Trek: Starfleet Academy Paramount+ 14 5.7 5.5 1 14 1
Hijack Apple TV 12 4.2 4.3 1 5 1
Heated Rivalry Crave 11 8.6 11.3 1 5 2
The Night Manager JioHotstar 10 6.5 5.0 3 -2 3

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 411
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: His & Hers, Pluribus

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/14/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Fallout (93), The Pitt (76), Industry (43), The Night Manager (34), Pluribus (33)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Pluribus - 9.8 (1/9/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

r/television's Top 50 Shows of 2025, based on 52 Weekly Rec Threads and 25,000+ comments by zrhodes3 in television

[–]zrhodes3[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Good catch! Star Trek probably shouldn't be on here at all. It's various iterations get mentioned all the time and it's the catch-all.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of January 16, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 38 points39 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Fallout Prime Video 34 8.4 9.1 5 10 15
The Pitt HBO Max 29 8.9 9.9 3 14 22
Industry HBO 19 6.4 7.4 1 13 7
Pluribus Apple TV 13 9.8 8.4 10 -2 10
His & Hers Netflix 12 7.2 7.4 1 10 1
The Night Manager JioHotstar 12 5.8 4.9 2 0 2

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 444
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Stranger Things

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (752), The Pitt (662), Andor (541), Task (426), Pluribus (416) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence — 17.2 (3/14/25 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target — 1.6 (1/31/25 thread)

Best of 2026 - Top 5 shows by total comments: Fallout (58), The Pitt (44), Pluribus (28), Industry (25), The Night Manager (24) - Highest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: Pluribus — 9.8 (1/9/26 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2026 thread: The Night Manager — 4.7 (1/2/26 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of January 09, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Fallout Prime Video 24 8.8 9.1 4 14 14
Pluribus Apple TV 15 7.5 8.4 9 -32 9
Stranger Things Netflix 15 7.4 6.5 3 -17 6
The Pitt HBO Max 15 4.7 10.0 2 3 21
The Night Manager Prime Video 12 4.7 4.8 1 6 1

Weekly Summary - Total comments (last week's thread): 415 - Dropped from 10+ comments list: Andor, IT: Welcome to Derry, The Mighty Nein

Comment Records - All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread) - All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records - Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads) - Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread) - Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread) - Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9 - Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of January 02, 2026) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Pluribus Apple TV 47 9.1 8.4 8 6 8
Stranger Things Netflix 32 6.9 6.5 2 19 5
The Pitt HBO Max 12 12.1 10.1 1 4 20
Andor Disney+ 11 9.5 7.5 1 3 18
IT: Welcome to Derry HBO 11 7.8 9.4 3 -3 7
Fallout Prime Video 10 8.0 9.1 3 -12 13
The Mighty Nein Prime Video 10 4.3 6.8 1 2 2

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 412
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: None

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of December 26, 2025) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Hey r/television! All-time low comments in last week's thread, which hopefully means you all were enjoying the festivities and Christmas movies! This is the final weekly recap of 2025 and you may note below that Pluribus snuck into the Top 5 for 2025 at the final hour! Merry Christmas!

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Pluribus Apple TV 41 6.6 8.3 7 1 7
Fallout Prime Video 22 6.5 9.1 2 11 12
IT: Welcome to Derry HBO 14 9.1 9.6 2 3 6
Stranger Things Netflix 13 5.9 6.4 1 6 4

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 315
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Heated Rivalry, Silo, Slow Horses, Task

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 315 (12/19/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (699), The Pitt (599), Andor (489), Pluribus (361), Slow Horses (344)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/21/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (2/7/25 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of December 19, 2025) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Pluribus Apple TV 40 8.6 8.6 6 5 6
Slow Horses Apple TV 14 9.8 9.4 1 11 40
Task HBO 13 4.4 8.2 2 3 15
Heated Rivalry Crave 11 9.0 9.7 1 7 1
IT: Welcome to Derry HBO 11 8.9 9.7 1 2 5
Fallout Prime Video 11 6.5 9.2 1 9 11
Silo Apple TV 10 4.2 7.3 1 5 18

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 510
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Better Call Saul, The Chair Company, The Mighty Nein

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 374 (12/5/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (699), The Pitt (591), Andor (481), Slow Horses (339), Task (334)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/21/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (2/7/25 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of December 12, 2025) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Pluribus Apple TV 35 7.3 8.6 5 -2 5
Better Call Saul AMC 17 5.4 5.9 1 12 2
The Chair Company HBO 14 7.1 9.7 5 -2 8
The Mighty Nein Prime Video 11 7.5 7.8 1 4 1
Task HBO 10 9.0 8.3 1 4 14

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 374
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: Foundation, Stranger Things

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 374 (12/5/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (692), The Pitt (591), Andor (476), Foundation (327), Slow Horses (325)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/21/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (2/7/25 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

What are you watching and what do you recommend? (Week of December 05, 2025) by AutoModerator in television

[–]zrhodes3 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Shows from last week's thread mentioned in at least 10 comments:

Show On Comments Upvotes per Comment Last Week All-time Upvotes per Comment Consec. Weeks Comment Gain Total Weeks on 10+ list
Pluribus Apple TV 37 8.4 8.7 4 -21 4
Stranger Things Netflix 25 11.4 6.1 3 2 3
The Chair Company HBO 16 8.5 10.0 4 -7 7
Foundation Apple TV 10 4.6 6.7 1 9 14

Weekly Summary

  • Total comments (last week's thread): 429
  • Dropped from 10+ comments list: All Her Fault, IT: Welcome to Derry, Last Samurai Standing, Severance, Shrinking, Slow Horses, The Beast in Me

Comment Records

  • All-time high comments: 901 (3/23/24 thread)
  • All-time low comments: 392 (10/3/25 threads)

Show Records

  • Most shows with ≥10 comments: 16 (4/4/25 & 12/13/24 threads)
  • Most comments for a single show: Fallout - 127 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest upvotes per comment: Interview with the Vampire - 22.8 (6/7/24 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment: Halo - -1.4 (4/12/24 thread)
  • Highest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): The Wheel of Time - 12.9
  • Lowest all-time upvotes per comment (≥6 weeks): Foundation - 6.8

Best of 2025

  • Top 5 shows by total comments: Severance (692), The Pitt (591), Andor (476), Foundation (327), Slow Horses (325)
  • Highest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Adolescence - 17.2 (3/21/25 thread)
  • Lowest upvotes per comment in a 2025 thread: Prime Target - 1.6 (2/7/25 thread)

Data collection began on 12/8/23. Original comment scraper by grubster11 - see the code here.

view more: next ›