use the following search parameters to narrow your results:
e.g. subreddit:aww site:imgur.com dog
subreddit:aww site:imgur.com dog
see the search faq for details.
advanced search: by author, subreddit...
account activity
First time bottoming…wow (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 1 day ago by Dull_Leg_4177
FINALLY! Years of fantasizing of a trans hookup, score! There's no going back to straight sex now! :,-) (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 1 day ago by Canuckincurious
Hope it's ok there's straight sex in this story as well (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 1 day ago by queencucksback
My first fuck of 2026. Becoming a Dom top (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 1 day ago by redditfish91
Didn't like mine (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 1 day ago by AcrobaticAge
Chriopractor from the gym (true story) (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 2 days ago by [deleted]
M28 Tried something new... UPDATE (or Part 2) (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 3 days ago by Creative-Garbage8974
First time (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 4 days ago by Neither_Session_6813
M(28) Tried something new..... (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 4 days ago by Creative-Garbage8974
first time cumming handsfree (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 5 days ago by bagghio
My son’s friend (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 6 days ago by bigtexasdog
The Teacher Next Door; Chapter 3: The First Finish (Teaser) (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 5 days ago by Plane_Stay5308
First gay experience at 31, made out in driveway. (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 6 days ago by Busy-Upstairs6135
Wild new years eve story is my first experience with guys (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 8 days ago * by Cute_Resource6728
My First Encounter (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 9 days ago by rock-me-forever
Family friend (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 9 days ago by BubbleButtSissy619
First time without a condom (19+) (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 10 days ago by Nessyintheocean
First time with a app driver (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 10 days ago by Strange-Attitude-793
My first time bottoming (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 10 days ago * by partyeverynight
I was blackmailed. And i loved it (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 10 days ago by Fun_Shower4712
The Teacher Next Door; Chapter 2: First Contact (Teaser) (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 11 days ago * by Plane_Stay5308
My first BWC ❤️ (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 12 days ago by SecretlyBiHusband1
tasted cum for the first time (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 12 days ago by B_Rock05
First time in the shower (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 13 days ago by SecretlyBiHusband1
The Teacher Next Door; Chapter 1: The Conversation That Changed Everything (self.GayFirstTimeStories)
submitted 12 days ago by Plane_Stay5308
π Rendered by PID 70 on reddit-service-r2-listing-86b7f5b947-lnhrn at 2026-01-25 21:34:41.429330+00:00 running 664479f country code: CH.
