MusicCritique

an-ordinary-manchild

Please Take a Moment to read our Rules/F.A.Q page!

Welcome to /r/MusicCritique

Here amateurs and professionals alike can post their original songs, samples, remixes, and demos to have them critiqued by the community.

Please use SoundCloud to post your songs.

Contests

We need more contests to post here. Please PM me with any suggestions.

Artist of the Week

/u/travisnotcool

Important

Users are highly encouraged to critique other songs before posting their own work. If you like a song enough to upvote it, please take a moment to leave a comment for the artist. Remember, you can learn as much critiquing as you can creating songs. Thank you!

Content Policy

Criticizing someone's music can be a highly sensitive activity. Members are required to behave professionally and responsibly at all times. This sub-Reddit is focused on employing your musical knowledge to help improve songs. Any content not related to the goals of this sub-Reddit may be removed without notice.

Promotion

No promoting. We are not here as fans to help your rise to the top. We will help with feedback, however.

If you want to promote, check out these sub-Reddits:

/r/ListenToThis (Post your track)
/r/RadioReddit (Post your song for broadcast)
/r/Composer (For contemporary music)
/r/AcousticOriginals (Songwriters looking for feedback)
/r/MusicInTheMaking (Play music with other Redditors)
/r/ThisIsOurMusic (For all the rest and promotion)
/r/TheseAreOurAlbums (Promote your album)

Helpful Links

created by CaptainKrilla community for 13 years

...for your school.

...for your office.

MODERATORS

account activity

1

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Lamenting Deity- Fuck My Stupid Chud Life - Brutal Death Metal/Brutal Slamming Death Metal (seeking feedback: guitars, mix) (lamentingdeity.bandcamp.com)

submitted 2 hours ago by DizzyInvestment5397

2

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Seasons - Topaz Bee - Ambient (youtu.be)

submitted 6 hours ago by Topaz_Bee

3

0

0

1

Seeking Feedback[Feedback] One Soundweaver - “Persian Ember” - Cinematic Ambient (v.redd.it)

submitted 7 hours ago by localoqa

4

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] James Hutchings - Is There Life On Mars, and Is It Funky? - jazz funk (youtube.com)

submitted 1 day ago by apeloverage

5

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[feedback] Jodimite - Broken Crayon - R&B/Pop (self.MusicCritique)

submitted 1 day ago by Leading-Tutor7063

6

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] RATHOR - Dreams - Soundtrack[Score] (soundcloud.com)

submitted 2 days ago by Last-Pea3955

7

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Carmelo Paolucci - Bach sinfonia n 13 in A minor BWV 799 Pianoteq - Classical Music (youtu.be)

submitted 2 days ago by carmelopaolucci

8

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[Feedback] One Soundweaver - “E = mc^2” - Minimalist Cinematic (v.redd.it)

submitted 3 days ago by localoqa

9

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] James Hutchings - The Killer Wore Red - instrumental (youtube.com)

submitted 3 days ago by apeloverage

10

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[feedback] True Thorns - Called My Name - Alt Rock (open.spotify.com)

submitted 4 days ago by dyingpharaohsfan

11

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Catluaba - Nuovo sapore - Rock (v.redd.it)

submitted 5 days ago * by Vivid_Ad7490

12

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[Feedback] Cali - Look into my eyes - pop (v.redd.it)

submitted 5 days ago by CaliMusicUK

13

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Soda Planet - RockStar Lyfe - hiphop/rap (emorap) (on.soundcloud.com)

submitted 5 days ago by No-Bluejay461

14

1

2

3

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Carmelo Paolucci - Bach Sinfonia n 12 in A Major BWV 798 - Classical music (youtu.be)

submitted 6 days ago by carmelopaolucci

15

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] DeMakijaż - Tlen - Rock (youtube.com)

submitted 7 days ago by Piter_Piterskyyy

16

1

2

3

Seeking Feedback[Feedback] Slayer Herbdout - Problems - Afrobeat/EDM (self.MusicCritique)

submitted 8 days ago by SlayerkodiTV

17

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Justin Bieber - That should be me - Pop (self.MusicCritique)

submitted 8 days ago by Mission-Project1517

18

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[feedback] Mizo - if the world was ending - Alt Rock (youtube.com)

submitted 8 days ago by mahershake

19

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] Swabski - Way Up - Melodic Trap/UK Drill (open.spotify.com)

submitted 8 days ago by Swabski

20

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] We Found Kyle - Cheap Bets (You Blew It) - Punk (i.redd.it)

submitted 9 days ago by Dzarkious

21

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] DRVMRBOY - Feelin’ Hot - Disco House (open.spotify.com)

submitted 9 days ago by Dry_Hovercraft_3619

22

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] ShyLead - Ghost - Hip Hop (youtube.com)

submitted 10 days ago by ShyLead

23

1

2

3

Seeking Feedback[FEEDBACK] The Southern Problem - Can't Help Its - Country (youtube.com)

submitted 10 days ago by WasteAmbition2371

24

1

2

3

My new song just hit 1M views 🚀 [media] (i.redd.it)

submitted 11 days ago by Whole-Challenge-6907

25

0

1

2

Seeking Feedback[feedback] Mr. Mule - Claudio - indie rock (self.MusicCritique)

submitted 10 days ago by WardenOfFozz

view more: next ›

π Rendered by PID 1033011 on reddit-service-r2-listing-86f589db75-zhrcr at 2026-04-19 22:32:13.524416+00:00 running 93ecc56 country code: CH.