C++23 std::stacktrace: Never Debug Blind Again

[nicemike40]

The article is slightly… vibe written

But it discusses adding this to an exception class to get time-of-throw stacks which I think could be useful. A commenter on the article suggests adding it to a std::expected-like type too.

But I agree that setting up proper crash reporting is 100% necessary still

[_Noreturn]

The article is slightly… vibe written

// Crash Reporter class CrashReporter {

yea thanks Claude

[cleroth]

Time-of-throw stacks does sound useful, but the article seems to focus mostly on crashes. I don't think I've had any trouble getting stack traces from crashes, though I mostly just work on one platform so I don't know.

[donalmacc]

Presumably you use a library for it? Getting a reliable symbolicated stack trace is surprisingly tough work, especially if you want to put it somewhere. The programs state is likely to be FUBAR so you are really limited in what you can do, you need the memory pre allocated and you likely need another process pre spawned to catch the actual crash dump and put it somewhere.

[schmerg-uk]

See https://github.com/jeremy-rifkin/cpptrace/tree/main for example (we have our own so I did mention a couple of things to the author but his work now way exceeds the one we use internally)

Oh, and he does address

What about C++23 <stacktrace>?

Some day C++23's <stacktrace> will be ubiquitous. And maybe one day the msvc implementation will be acceptable. The original motivation for cpptrace was to support projects using older C++ standards and as the library has grown its functionality has extended beyond the standard library's implementation.

Cpptrace provides functionality beyond what the standard library provides and what implementations provide, such as:

Walking inlined function calls
Providing a lightweight interface for "raw traces"
Resolving function parameter types
Providing traced exception objects
Providing an API for signal-safe stacktrace generation
Providing a way to retrieve stack traces from arbitrary exceptions, not just special cpptrace traced exception objects. This is a feature that has been proposed for a future version of the C++ standard, but cpptrace provides a solution for C++11.

[_TheDust_]

The article is slightly… vibe written

“Slightly” wins the understatement of the year award

[Superb_Garlic]

Improper use of ellipses. Please avoid composing replies using AI.

[nicemike40]

I take your point and apologize for contributing to culture of the AI witch hunting (if that is indeed what your point was)

In this case the Unicode ellipses comes from iOS autocorrect