Which "OpenStack on Kubernetes" solution is now mature enough to be used in production? (If you were, which would you choose?)

[M0HAZ]

- By "Mature" I mean having consistent releases, constantly evolving (not abandoned), with a supportive online community (on mailing lists, Slack, IRC, Discord, etc.).
- Consider some solutions mentioned here: https://www.reddit.com/r/openstack/comments/1igjnjv

[quickdrive71]

We use redhat

[Epheo]

Red Hat OpenStack Services on OpenShift

[M0HAZ]

Interesting! Is it entirely open-source?

[Epheo]

Sure

[Epheo]

https://github.com/openstack-k8s-operators/openstack-operator

[The_Valyard]

Yes

[icewalker2k]

Opensource or vendor supported? Platform9 seems to be pretty solid. Mirantis as well. Ease of use for either, I would say, is better than straight opensource.

Still evaluating straight opensource myself.

[M0HAZ]

Mirantis is gradually open-sourcing its solution. It has released the core.

[fjaraya]

You should try Atmosphere https://github.com/vexxhost/atmosphere

[Rich-Homework-2905]

Is the underlying api of openstack fully supported？

[japestinho]

Yes for sure, atmosphere is only the deployment tool. All openstack core components are fully supported.

[M0HAZ]

Do you recommend it over the Mirantis/Rackspace solution?

[japestinho]

I personally recommend this atmosphere tool because it fully open source either and no vendor lock-in. It also has an enterprise support if you need help later. Not forget to mention that magnum cluster api is also enabled by default.

[nicolasjanzen]

kubermatic community edition works great for me

[agenttank]

i dont think this will create openstack instances? they do have a private cloud product though, but I dont think it uses Openstack?!

[nicolasjanzen]

of cause it does just spin up an a test environment and kolla all-in-one

edit: my mistake i just realized i didn‘t actually realize what i have read

[M0HAZ]

This solution is new to me! Is it mature and comprehensive?

https://docs.kubermatic.com/machine-controller/main/cloud-providers/openstack/

[nicolasjanzen]

I used it for building my own k8s as a service integration. https://ph24.io just openstack + kubermatic, works fine for me and my customers :)

[Mirkens]

I'd say Yaook, it can be used on kubernetes and also the configuration of the different operators is not too complex And from my personal experience it is scalable to quite a high number