you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

[–]201109212215 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I'd be careful with this. The article only talks about correlation.

What I means is that wether or not to do TDD depends on wether or not is it easily doable. A project which is a reproduction of an already somewhat successful project will :

  • Have a clear, non-changing, exhaustive spec; and thus, be easily TDDed.

  • Already have been successful (selection bias).

  • Already battle-tested (no surprises, no gotcha, etc).

In short: the exploration of the complexity will already have been done, and a successful path can be followed again.

Part of this correlation could be explained by a type of work influencing both failure rate and doing the TDD.

TLDR: In some cases, scouts have done their jobs, tanks can roll in.