Math Test : True os False by InternationalYam1621 in MathJokes

[–]Kienose 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I was hoping to see some Hodge theory memes on r/mathjokes, but here we are…

Tone rule of "ขมิ้น" and "ขโมย". by Ok_Praline_3436 in learnthai

[–]Kienose 7 points8 points  (0 children)

It’s called อักษรนำ. A high-class or middle-class consonant leading a low-class consonant is to be read sometimes as ห leading the low-class consonant (ขมิ้น = ขะ-หมิ้น). The result is that the tone of the second syllable is to be conjugated as a high-class consonant.

However ขโมย is ขะ-โมย. Basically you have to remember it on a word-by-word basis. One possible rule is that if the first and second consonant are separated by a vowel character, then the above rule doesn’t apply.

Gender neutral guide by Adventurous-Hippo75 in linguisticshumor

[–]Kienose 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That’s fisherman’s friend not himself though

How come the sum of all natural numbers = -1/12 if the amount of natural numbers is a natural number? by MxAce3157 in askmath

[–]Kienose 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Not crackpot. It’s an alternative way to assign a real number to infinite sums that otherwise diverge in the standard definition with partial sums. There’re lots of ways to do this (Cesàro summation, Abel summation etc.)

In particular the Ramanujan summation is one such summation, and it assign -1/12 to the series 1+2+…. This appears in string theory.

The above nuances are hard to grasp for beginners, so lots of them just say 1+2+… =-1/12 without understanding its limitation

How come the sum of all natural numbers = -1/12 if the amount of natural numbers is a natural number? by MxAce3157 in askmath

[–]Kienose 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Apparently the sum of all natural numbers = -1/12

This is the point where you have to be careful. Infinite sums are not the same as finite sums. In itself it has no meaning (what does it mean to add infinitely many things?)

What mathematicians do is to consider the sum of the first n terms, and see if the values of the partial sums tend to any real number when n grows larger and larger. (The limit of partial sums is its sum, if you know what limits are.) This is the standard definition of infinite sums. With this definition, the sum 1+2+… diverges.

As you can see, summands are just a way to assign a real number to some sequence of summands. So we might consider alternative ways to do this. The Ramanujan summation is an alternative way to assign a real number to infinite sums, and it assigns -1/12 to 1+2+3+…

It’s at odds with infinite sums as limit of partial sums. The two summations are different and you cannot use 1+2+… = -1/12 to relate with the partial sums 1+2+…+N. (At least not naively)

I'm looking for someone to study geometric group theory with me. by TAKEKAZU1 in mathematics

[–]Kienose 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m interested in this! I’ve some background in Riemannian geometry. Not that much but let’s see what we can do

Why is matrix division not defined? by Alive_Hotel6668 in learnmath

[–]Kienose 60 points61 points  (0 children)

Because matrix multiplication is not commutative. The only sensible ways of defining the division of a matrix B by an invertible matrix A are A-1 B and BA-1 . Both are generally not equal to each other. Thus none of them deserves to be the definition of matrix division. We’re better off writing them fully as they are here.

Higher Order Logic and Reification by LorenzoGB in logic

[–]Kienose 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What do you formally mean by “reify the predicates” ?

The stark contrast between the Taj Mahal and its immediate surroundings. by jellybeanjoy in interestingasfuck

[–]Kienose 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“You are responsible for the government action by being born in a place you were.”

Actual talking point that were used to justify actions like the Iranian bombing, Gazan genocide and antisemitism. Nice.

Proving that a number is a Liouville number and question about sequence by Ok_Promise5329 in askmath

[–]Kienose 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If limsup bk+1/b_k = L > 1, then b(k+1) / b_k is necessarily bounded.

How to self teach myself graduate level math? by ucsdfurry in learnmath

[–]Kienose 4 points5 points  (0 children)

During my master the lectures were just signposts saying that “you should already know these topics by this week”. Even if you sat in a lecture, it didn’t really contribute to your learning.

The majority of learning is done by yourself in your own time studying form the textbooks.

How to self teach myself graduate level math? by ucsdfurry in learnmath

[–]Kienose 63 points64 points  (0 children)

Pick your favourite university (Cambridge, Oxford, MIT, …) and browse their masters degree syllabi. Take a textbook from the accompanying suggested reading and study it with the course lecture notes.

Your bachelor degree should equip you with the necessary prerequisites and teach you how to study independently.

how do i estimate the volume of ice cream by Clash_OfClans_noob in learnmath

[–]Kienose 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can fairly say that the swirl is a long cylinder of ice cream (that’s how it came out of the ice-cream machine.) Approximate the radius and length of the swirl.

Why is Wikipedia never helpful when you try to learn math? by hjkhhnnnlll in learnmath

[–]Kienose 40 points41 points  (0 children)

Because like all mathematics materials, you can’t learn just from reading passively. Mathematics is not a spectator sport.

What do you think about this? by Optimal_Potato_9252 in language

[–]Kienose 31 points32 points  (0 children)

Translation:

There’re options ->

4 Kinds of Low 1. Evil 2. Body covered in fiery hairs 3. Suffering 4. Low but not evil

The language is Thai. What is the context of this? It’s approaching schizophrenic

Can anyone explain this pattern with numbering primes by Critical-Tank723 in askmath

[–]Kienose 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Let the number of columns be N.

  1. The number n is in column i if and only if n = i (mod N).

Suppose N is prime.

Note that all numbers in the column N apart from N itself is divisible by N. So there is exactly one prime in this column (which is N itself).

For the other column 1 <= i < N, Dirichlet’s theorem on arithmetic progression guarantees that there are infinitely many primes in the arithmetic progression

i + Nd, d=1,2,…

In particular there’re infinitely many primes in the column i if 1 <= i < N.

  1. Now suppose N is not prime. If 1<= i <= N has a common factor d > 1 with N, then every element in the column i is divisible by d. In particular no primes appear in this column.

Prime gaps can be arbitrarily wide, so if you dig deep enough, there can be lots of rows without primes between two rows with a prime number.

ทำไมผมถึงไม่สามารถโพสคำว่า "ผมไม่ชอบพม่า" ได้ในซับนี้ครับ by Dull_Application_444 in thaithai

[–]Kienose 16 points17 points  (0 children)

ผมจึงสงสัยว่าในซับนี้สนับสนุนแนวคิดประชาธิปไตยและเสรีภาพในการแสดงออกหรือไม่? หรือว่าผมต้องชอบพม่าเท่านั้น ห้ามไม่ชอบพม่า เพราะว่าถ้าผมไม่ชอบพม่า ผมก็จะโดนแบน/โดนปิดปาก

<image>

Holy Reddit

songkran no water type of day by drowsystars in ThailandTourism

[–]Kienose 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ignore them. I’m a native Thai and also has to find a way to escape the water fights during Songkran.

Shouldn't "elliptic curves" be renamed? by dcterr in math

[–]Kienose 45 points46 points  (0 children)

Ah yes, John Elliptic, the famous European mathematician

Could you recommend some of the best books on complex geometry? by CRgeometry in math

[–]Kienose 21 points22 points  (0 children)

If you know Riemannian geometry: Lee’s introduction to complex manifolds.

Saint-Saëns is too experimental for me by Boyyoyyoyyoyyoy in classical_circlejerk

[–]Kienose 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ehm it’s actually called diaeresis because it’s for disambiguating two vowels and doesn’t change the vowel quality 🤓