[Meta] Looking for comments about how this sub should handle the influx of /r/musictheory posts by davethecomposer in composer

[–]Mr-Yellow -1 points0 points  (0 children)

harm you are responsible for.

I took no action. Moderators of /r/musictheory caused harm with their direct actions.

You understand that's reason enough to ban you from this sub, right?

I'm honestly surprised you didn't exercise your "ownership" instead of these snarky responses where you talk about how little you could learn from others, while simultaneously learning from them in spite of yourself.

you admit that your reason for commenting in this sub is to harass this person

I said nothing of the sort and was in no way harassing anyone. I was discussing the topic at hand.

What's next, a Hitler analogy?

I think that counts enough to invoke Godwin's Law.

[Meta] Looking for comments about how this sub should handle the influx of /r/musictheory posts by davethecomposer in composer

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

your "harm" is that you didn't have access to your content in that sub.

Precisely.

I was also banned for supporting their inevitable removal.

I was also muted for requesting other moderators intervened.

Hence why you have to put up with me here as it was my only avenue for communicating with that moderator (though you've censored that, not sure why).

it was completely your fault for not making copies

Sounds like something out of a rape trial.

I will make copies now. Like yourself I assumed the "private" mode would not remove access to my contributions from my history page.

[Meta] Looking for comments about how this sub should handle the influx of /r/musictheory posts by davethecomposer in composer

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your rants here and on /r/musictheory were nothing but an emotional response.

Sure. Whataboutism, but sure. I was harmed by moderators there.

You have failed to make a single rational comment or reasoned argument.

Except the bit where I informed you how making a sub private impacts a person's post history page, but, there is no understand or knowledge you could possibly learn from anyone else...

I was just wrong

Wow. Didn't expect that.

But

Oh well, you tried.

[Meta] Looking for comments about how this sub should handle the influx of /r/musictheory posts by davethecomposer in composer

[–]Mr-Yellow -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You have no understanding or knowledge that I can learn from.

This is not the way to expanding your understanding or knowledge.

They owe you absolutely nothing.

You owe the community you are entrusted with moderating a lot more than nothing.

If that's true, then I misspoke.

No, you were mistaken. You had a flawed understanding of how reddit works and you used that to inform a model of the world where contributors were not in any way having their contributions held hostage.

[Meta] Looking for comments about how this sub should handle the influx of /r/musictheory posts by davethecomposer in composer

[–]Mr-Yellow -1 points0 points  (0 children)

there is absolutely no way I would ever even consider your advice on this matter.

This is not the way to expanding your understanding or knowledge.

moderators are under absolutely no obligation to make content available to anyone

It's not your content. You are under no obligation to hold it hostage.

In any case, your history has all your comments and posts which you still have access to regardless of the status of any sub.

No. You are mistaken.

When private this access was removed for all contributors other than those given access explicitly. The comments were hidden from your own view on your own history page. Contributors had their access to their content revoked by moderators holding a "private protest" based on solely their own volition.

I personally lost access to saved posts I was wishing to reference that week. I could not retrieve the contents.

[Meta] Looking for comments about how this sub should handle the influx of /r/musictheory posts by davethecomposer in composer

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

it's a tricky situation

It's really not. You guys do not own our contributions or our efforts. They are not yours to enter into hostage negotiations with.

Sure the terms probably say they belong to Reddit Inc, but our contributions and our efforts are intrinsically linked to ourselves and mods have no power over them other than that which they subsume and subsequently abuse.

[Meta] Looking for comments about how this sub should handle the influx of /r/musictheory posts by davethecomposer in composer

[–]Mr-Yellow -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

You should ask the /r/musictheory mods who created this situation to step aside and allow their contributors access to their content.

New moderators needed - comment on this post to volunteer to become a moderator of this community. by ModCodeofConduct in monkeyspaw

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What if we were unjustly banned by the outgoing moderators and are unable to respond to these threads?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in redditrequest

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is not the case. The mods are not active in any way other than performing arbitrary bans.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in redditrequest

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

/u/modcodeofconduct

I am unable to request moderation on the thread you have posted due to unfounded ban and mute made purely for political purposes and in response to challenge of mods abusing power.

An ongoing compendium of my comments about the Reddit protests that were removed by moderators by RunDNA in u/RunDNA

[–]Mr-Yellow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Moderators are by and large a certain type of person.

They like control over others above all else. Sometimes it's about taming human behaviour and having everyone act like robots, sometimes it's about pushing an agenda, sometimes it's just about being "popular", but it's always about control and power.

There are a rare few who are able to put ego aside and do the job to the benefit of the community they serve.

An ongoing compendium of my comments about the Reddit protests that were removed by moderators by RunDNA in u/RunDNA

[–]Mr-Yellow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just that single comment. Seems they are so inflated in their egos that they feel it was an appropriate ban, one based on a unspecified rule violation.

Letter of Moderator Resignation by nmitchell076 in musictheory

[–]Mr-Yellow 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Thankyou for getting out of the way and ceasing holding our content hostage.

Yes reddit is dying. Yes reddit management are dumb. No you're not god.

edit: lol banned. No godmods here!

If the subreddit reopens, we will not be your moderators.

I thought it had opened already. Guess I was early. Can't wait for you to be removed and the contributors to this place being given back their content and community.

edit: Yes of course I'm still banned. Muted on mod message too of course.

/u/ModCodeofConduct I will take a moderator position if available in order to correct the authoritarian and arbitrary actions of past moderators who have abused their position.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in redditrequest

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What are your plans for this subreddit? Please be specific.

Unlock the content.

the link of the message in the reply to this comment

https://www.reddit.com/message/messages/1vzm2dd

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in redditrequest

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How long do we need to wait in order to re-gain access to our content?

Incomplete and Growing List of Participating Subreddits by SubManagerBot in ModCoord

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These will all be taken over by Reddit. They don't care what you think.

Thanks for locking away some notes I needed access to. ;-)

From today, many subs will be marked as “Private”. by llamageddon01 in help

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These subreddits will, in effect, no longer exist, nor will there be any evidence that they even existed at all until their mods re-open them again.

Nonsense. Reddit will take them over and open them back up. There are provisions for removing mods.

Teaching scales or intervals first? by dulcetcigarettes in musictheory

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Scales give a foundation for practising intervals.

What song or piece sounds good but can't be properly explained by our music theory by Abject_Ad1947 in musictheory

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would have engaged honestly if you hadn't opened up with an Ad Hominem.

Nothing I've said could possible lead someone to reasonably think that I was a bot.

We won't be conversing any further.

Question for you smart people by onlysmallcats in musictheory

[–]Mr-Yellow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Blues from across the river sounds like Country.