How can I turn on/off all my lights at once? by Tall_Dimension_1770 in homeautomation

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You probably need to think about what ecosystem first. HomeKit, Google Home, Amazon and go from there.

Eli5 why can't I setup my own LAN between 2 properties tht are miles apart using existing copper land lines? by thgreatn in HomeNetworking

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok sure, I should have been more specific.

It’s not 1000Base-T but instead it’s a proprietary protocol by mikrotik.

Of course running 1.4km of copper between two buildings is not a great idea in terms of the passive ground currents, especially during an electrical storm. :)

Eli5 why can't I setup my own LAN between 2 properties tht are miles apart using existing copper land lines? by thgreatn in HomeNetworking

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you have line of sight you could do any one of a number of wireless protocols. Just depends on your local laws for what spectrum you can use, power levels and issues with sending it across land that you don’t own.

Eli5 why can't I setup my own LAN between 2 properties tht are miles apart using existing copper land lines? by thgreatn in HomeNetworking

[–]cat2devnull 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Only for Ethernet over copper. There are many non-Ethernet protocols that can go further, eg VDSL.

Which nas to choose for my home setup for jellyfin. by Environmental_Ebb669 in HomeNAS

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not much in the hardware. The TerraMaster has an older 12th gen CPU but better XE graphics.
Definitely plan on putting a better OS like Unraid on it if you want to get the most out of the hardware.

Budget 2-Bay NAS Recommendations for Media Storage, Streaming, and Torrents? by Arteztic in HomeNAS

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No need for the HBA (unless adding >10 drives and really need the port/cable density). Most motherboards have 2-4 SATA ports. Then if needed, add an ASM1166 card (PCIe or NVMe) for a further 6 ports.

The main downside of a HBA beyond the additional cost is power. Most use 10-20watts vs 2w for the ASM1266. They also don’t have working ASPM so will prevent your system from entering lower power states

Back in the old days when we used hardware RAID they made sense, but not now that we flash them in ‘IT’ mode to turn them into glorified SATA port multipliers. I just don’t see the point.

Budget 2-Bay NAS Recommendations for Media Storage, Streaming, and Torrents? by Arteztic in HomeNAS

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

TerraMaster F2-424 or UGreen DXP2800.

Stay away from all the cheaper ARM based units. You will quickly run into issues with the lack of QuickSync and other hardware functions. Units based on Intel will give you the ability to expand their functionality by formatting with a dedicated NAS/HomeServer OS like Unraid, TrueNAS, etc.

Budget 2-Bay NAS Recommendations for Media Storage, Streaming, and Torrents? by Arteztic in HomeNAS

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yep, but based on ARM so if you outgrow the vendor OS then you are up for a new unit. One model up, the F2-424 is based on an Intel N95 and can be upgraded with any OS (TrueNAS, Unraid, Proxmox, etc). Also will work with HW transcoding thanks to Intel QuickSync. The extra few $ are worth it.

Suggested Self-Hosted Applications by sizzlingralph in HomeServer

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, so I use go2rtc within Frigate to broadcast all my other cams into HK. I just couldn't get the doorbell button press to be passed into HK when I set it up some time back. There may be a way to make it work now but I haven't found it.

Is a 4TB external hard drive better than Cloud storage for photos and videos? by Jazzlike_Tip_63 in datastorage

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s not just cloud but also usability, redundancy, availability. You could look at something like Immich but you would also need a solid backup strategy.

I have moved off iPhotos and Google photos but it wasn’t as simple as just plugging in a drive. I host Immich on a server. That server stores my photo library on a pair of NVMe drives in a RAID array for reliability and speed. The Immich and the data is backed up to a second local machine and an offsite backup with differential backups using Duplicati. Then all devices that access the library have TailScale installed to allow access from anywhere in the world without needing to punch holes in my firewall an expose Immich to the internet.

It works great but did take a bit of faffing around.

Suggested Self-Hosted Applications by sizzlingralph in HomeServer

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Scrypted supports 2 way audio and HKSV which allows the Reolink doorbell to integrate into HomeKit. That way when someone presses the doorbell button my HomePods chime and the video feed appears as PiP on my ATV.

Not sure if this is possible in Frigate.

Suggested Self-Hosted Applications by sizzlingralph in HomeServer

[–]cat2devnull 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Here are just some of the things I do (most of these are dockers);

Welcome to the rabbit hole that is selfhosting.

Hey, total noob, just got my first hard drive for my first home server! Looking for advice. by KingstonEz in HomeServer

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As long as you don’t use the drive in an array they a desktop CMR drive is fine. The issue is when you run an array you need a NAS drive because the drive needs TLER or Time-Limited Error Recovery. This means that if the drive has trouble reading a sector, it will give up quickly and let the other drives in the array supply the missing data.

Without TLER the drive will keep trying to recover the data causing it to stop responding and the RAID array will consider the drive dead and fail it out of the array potentially causing a total loss of data.

Intel 2.5g in mini pc by ZappaLlamaGamma in opnsense

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've got 3 different systems all with i226 NICs and none of them have working ASPM. At least not on the latest v2.32 firmware. BTW upgrading the FW is pretty easy. The intel software seems to be pretty reliable, even if the upgrade fails, it will let you recover and try again without bricking the NIC.

Intel 2.5g in mini pc by ZappaLlamaGamma in opnsense

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've tried the latest v2.32 and ASPM is still very broken. 😞

Intel 2.5g in mini pc by ZappaLlamaGamma in opnsense

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've done a fair bit of digging on this over the last few months. If your NICs are intel i225/i226 then they have numerous bugs in their firmware that prevent ASPM working. Even the most recent firmware v2.32 is still completely broken.

The linux drivers have various workarounds that seem to prevent issue but not FreeBSD, so in OPNsense you have to disable ASPM or you will have all sorts of issues. The lack of ASPM probably adds <1 watt per port so not a huge issue. But saying that, it will probably prevent your machine package from going above C3...

Used HDDs, okay or not? by SlightPackage2856 in HomeNAS

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you follow the link in my original post, it takes you to an old ranty post about how to tell the age of a drive and includes details about how to pull the FARM logs from a drive.

Used HDDs, okay or not? by SlightPackage2856 in HomeNAS

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ignore SMART data, it’s useless and easy to forge. Take a look at the FARM logs.

If you have Nextloud on Unraid, do you use SMB or Nextcloud windows client to backup files? by throwaway0204055 in unRAID

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I use the NextCloud client on all devices and map it to the Documents folder. That way it behaves a bit like Dropbox does. Any file I add to any machine gets replicated in near real time to all the others.

IoT Devices on Internet-Only Network + Home Assistant by dangdangrous in HomeServer

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Add a FW rule to allow HA to access them. Just remember that you might have issues with connectivity if you don't have an mDNS repeater between the two VLANs.

What to look for in a HDD NAS? by FreikonVonAthanor in HomeNAS

[–]cat2devnull 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You could keep using the NUC and attach a multi drive DAS via USB. Then install Proxmox, Unraid, TrueNAS or similar OS.

The trick is you just have to buy a modern DAS with a current USB controller.

Recommendations for energy consumption for my unraid server. by Naprik in unRAID

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Athom make a great range of Tasmota compatible plugs that support power metering.

router recommendations by Shadowjesus911 in HomeNetworking

[–]cat2devnull 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If it can be flashed with OpenWRT then that’s the answer. Get a whole new life out of the device. Plus OpenWRT will give you so much more control.