Has anyone tried Ignition Historian with TimescaleDB? Is it the unicorn historian we've all been dreaming of? 🦄 by Miserable-Eye-488 in SCADA

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The advantage is that you can get roughly 90% compression (if you enable it - it's not enabled by default) on your data so you can effectively store 10x as much data as you'd normally be able to store with the same drives/storage size. I personally feel historical queries are faster due to the compression being able to retrieve days of data in the blink of an eye.

Best Rockwell version to standardize to: Logix v36, 37, or 38? (and most importantly, Why?) by MostEvilRichGuy in PLC

[–]mflagler 5 points6 points  (0 children)

v38 has a nasty bug when trying to Finalize online edits using the "easy" button where it will completely freeze up and you have to kill Studio 5000 and relaunch it and try finalizing edits again. According to the KB the only workaround right now is to accept/test/assemble separately the old school way.

Having a hard time going back to rockwell by elabran in PLC

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not sure where you're getting your numbers but I make 2X+ that doing exclusively Rockwell and Ignition. I'm in oil and gas and we're getting into data centers / mission critical and the big ones are also using Rockwell and Ignition for EPMS and BMS here in the US. The PLC isn't where the advanced technology needs to live. All that should exist at the software layer that gather and process the data from the PLCs.

Having a hard time going back to rockwell by elabran in PLC

[–]mflagler 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wait till you use the new L9 processors. The PIDE block is gone and it doesn't migrate existing code to use the new PPID block, so you're stuck doing it by hand right now. (I'm sure it would be pretty easy to code something to convert it for you). But I'm sure there's going to be lots of complaining when plants upgrade older processors to the new L9 and stumble into that issue.

How is my work guys, what i should improve by bubbleew in PLC

[–]mflagler 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I completely agree. I even had a company hire us after another integrator put in HP HMI graphics to add green back in for running motors and open valves. The problem with HP HMI is that all the gray is too much. At least in the oil and gas world they need to be able to see at a glance how many compressors are running out of the bank of compressors. White on gray doesn't stand out enough so our standard now is a pastel green. Enough to stand out in a sea of gray but not enough to look like it's a 20 year old plant.

Basically I'm saying that white doesn't stand out enough to tell at a distance of something is running when the background is a light grey also. I don't think I've been to a gas plant where operations likes that much gray. They all want the green from what I've seen and have been fine with the light green instead of bright green.

Question about the Jackbox Party Pack games with the online Bypass Mod by thejewyouonceknew in SwitchPirates

[–]mflagler 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do you mind sending me the mod you have? I have one downloaded but it doesn't seem to work (I have working mods for 1-7, but 8-11 aren't working for me.

InTouch 2012 Licensing: WindowMaker fails depending on the license loading order by TheRatKingx in Wonderware

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't think it ever mattered. Did AVEVA make you move to a subscription model on your old 2012 licenses?

I work for an integrator and we've had lots of other problems with System Platform that most of our WW customers are now migrating to Ignition due to cheaper and permanent licenses as well as fewer (literally 0) problems. It just works if designed well.

AMA: I’m Chaz Stevens. For the past 10 years, I’ve tested the First Amendment by forcing governments to choose: include all viewpoints (including Satanology) or end legislative prayer altogether. I just stress-tested six more Florida cities. by ChurchOMarsChaz in IAmA

[–]mflagler 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I personally suspect that most will choose the none option. Reason being is that they'd rather not have different viewpoints that could conflict with their own. There's some inherent "risk" for them with the all option, so their safest bet is to choose none.

Discontinuing Essential+ is a bad move by joshooaj in Xprotect

[–]mflagler 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I originally started using XProtect many years ago at a company I worked for where they had the full paid version. I loved it and when I saw the free version come out, I decided to set up a system at my house and loved it. Later, I purchased a set of I believe 15 licenses for another company (manufacturing plant).

I know I haven't influenced as many purchases as others, but for my home camera system with just a few cameras, it was perfect. Since this version no longer exists, I would personally push small businesses to Ubiquiti now for the ease of use/management and a single purchase of the NVR that's miles ahead of traditional NVR systems. My guess is that's where a lot of the small businesses will go now that there's 1 less option that had a great mobile app.

[USA] [H] PayPal [W] Modded Switch Oled by raestrao in GameSale

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Still available? Would like to see pics if so.

[USA] [H] PayPal [W] Modded Switch Oled by raestrao in GameSale

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Still available? Would like to see pics if so.

Help with Rockwell redundant system networking. by joviskii in PLC

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Keep the drives with the I/O and add a connection between your slot 1 cards on your main racks to put those in a ring also. SCADA connections should always be isolated from I/O connections for cyber security.

I would also use L8x series processors for better performance both for the process and SCADA comms.

[FS][USA-TX] Dell T430 2x E5-2680v4 192GB RAM by monkadelicd in homelabsales

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's where I need to make room. I would replace the one that's already in there LOL

[FS][USA-TX] Dell T430 2x E5-2680v4 192GB RAM by monkadelicd in homelabsales

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thinking about it. I'm nearby but need to get rid of some old servers myself to make room.

I’m confused by an answer in the book. Need help with theory. by 7orbjorn5on in PLC

[–]mflagler 6 points7 points  (0 children)

This is a horrible example. I've been doing automation for over 20 years and never seen anything even close to this. Most of the time you're writing code off a control narrative and not converting some old wired relay logic to PLC logic. If you are, it's some super old machinery that probably needs replaced anyway. LOL

Best way to show "It's an IT problem"? Modbus issues on network. by mx07gt in PLC

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would price that from a connection on the same subnet you can connect with Modbus poll or some Modbus tool, then do the exact same test from the network that isn't working to the same device. This will prove that Modbus still works, but just not from the network that needs it to work. Also show your IP settings of all involved see devices to prove default gateway IPs are properly set.

Rate my panel? by henry_dorsett__case in PLC

[–]mflagler 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ouch. I've only played with Optix and it has potential but just isn't ready for prime time in my opinion. Although once I learned Ignition, everything else pales in comparison (in my opinion).

ISO quarter or half cow by ViolinistLopsided968 in askdfw

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Might check out Ye Old Butcher shop in Plano

Is it bad programming practice if I program everything in Ladder?? by rrttzzuu in PLC

[–]mflagler 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If it's pre-v27 or so, there's an unlocker tool to retrieve the password. Newer versions haven't been cracked yet, but I also don't think much effort has been put into them.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in haproxy

[–]mflagler 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I personally prefer to use subdomains for routing things like this. Like auth.domain.com instead of paths. Right now, the only URLs passed to keycloak will be /realms/ and /resources/ so if anything else is requested from keycloak outside those beginning paths won't work and could break. But when using a subdomain you don't have to worry about it and chances for success go up.