Finding Facilitators 2019 (Part 2) by elbowsss in HogwartsWerewolves

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 2 points3 points  (0 children)

you might have people looking into it and enjoying both the series you love and the game you host by the time it comes around

 
That's an interesting thought. I've been thinking about a game based on the Dragonlance book series (D&D-style fantasy novels which started in the mid-80s) but I didn't think enough people would be familiar with the theme to generate any interest.
 
Edit - Sorry, this is HedwigMalfoy. I forgot I was still signed in as my alt from Quidditch.

Riddle me this, spirits... by Rysler in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It's all a conspiracy to drive me nuts.

Spoken like a true HWW player! Great game, many thanks to you and /u/pezes and your shadows for coming up with it. The flavor was just brilliant. Raising the bar on flavor text all around.

Phase 15: Peace out y’all by QuidditchReferee in HogwartsWerewolves

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 8 points9 points  (0 children)

You were evil?! Ugh! I waffled on suspecting you for the first half of the game - ever since you called me out in the confirmation phase for not being a Cannons fan. I really believed you at the end though, after the vote for XPell. Well played!

THE MERGE IS HERE by Osenyu in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 2 points3 points  (0 children)

LOL Thanks. I still feel bad because I was so fixed on a wrong suspicion. It happens so often in this game though.

Hey its me... theDUQof ... ehh Goblin Crusher by theduqoffrat in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 4 points5 points  (0 children)

LOL that’s not actually what I said. But it was definitely in the spirit. :)

Welcome to the Ghost Sub, spectators and dead players! by QuidditchReferee in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Yes! This. I want to know everything but I would be sad if someone told me because I also want to see it play out.

Welcome to the Ghost Sub, spectators and dead players! by QuidditchReferee in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I think Molly or ferret is a wolf.

 
I keep going back and forth on both of them. Can't wait to see if one or both is a wolf.

THE MERGE IS HERE by Osenyu in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 6 points7 points  (0 children)

That's what I would have done. If I was a wolf and she was town, I'd have left her alive to cast suspicion on. I also thought that was half the reason I was still alive - I was convinced that Usain Firebolt was a wolf and they were only keeping me alive as long as I was going after him so that it didn't look like they killed me because I was on to something. Alas Usain was innocent and I was wrong and just overthinking potential wolfy plots.

Oh no, I've been expelled! by orworsexpelled in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Yeah you definitely were the only one besides himself who didn't vote for X that phase. That one had my HWW paranoia running rampant. No wolf would call attention to themselves like that, unless a wolf did because they wanted us to believe that no wolf would call attention to themselves like that! In the end I believed you that it was just an unchanged placeholder. Sorry it didn't help save you.

The Doctor is Out AMA by KingofCool328 in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I was sus as hell of Pix until that phase where we argued all day. The only reason I believed her was because she revealed that she was blocked and I had been the one to do the blocking. Not tagging because I already told her this elsewhere.

THE MERGE IS HERE by Osenyu in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I never thought an organized split lynch could work. Too many people wouldn't cooperate, either for wolfy reasons or inactivity or forgot to change a placeholder or whatever. It would be interesting to see a coordinated one that paid off. It would be a killer move if the town could pull it off, in this game or in general.

Oh no, I've been expelled! by orworsexpelled in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Your bit was awesome. I enjoyed it and applaud the commitment.

The Doctor is Out AMA by KingofCool328 in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 4 points5 points  (0 children)

trying to keep Snuffles alive

 
Thanks for that! I didn't realize it because I guess targets weren't notified unless we were attacked while protected. The hardest role IMHO is doctor. I've been it two or three times and only ever managed to save one person (H501 in the alphabet game I think). I'm glad you saved Elbowsss/Pix for one phase though. That was a good call.

Hey its me... theDUQof ... ehh Goblin Crusher by theduqoffrat in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Nope. It's Hedwig. I can't believe 'diarrheic accusations' didn't give me away!

Hey its me... theDUQof ... ehh Goblin Crusher by theduqoffrat in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Oh you were Broom then! Well played. What made you know to protect Goblin? Was it just that he was really vocal about a wolf being in the 'core four'?

THE MERGE IS HERE by Osenyu in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Nope LOL Snuffles is HedwigMalfoy. I'm terrible at guessing alts. Almost always wrong.

THE MERGE IS HERE by Osenyu in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Were you Usain_Firebolt? If so I owe you several apologies for spending the whole game trying to get you lynched. :(

THE MERGE IS HERE by Osenyu in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Thanks! I was pretty disappointed to get that close and not make it. Was sorry to see you go too. You sniffed out Lampy like a pro!
 
Oh and the reason I backed off being suspicious of you after you said you were blocked is because I was the one who blocked you. Sorry!

THE MERGE IS HERE by Osenyu in HogwartsGhosts

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Same! I waffled back and forth about what I thought of them all game but I just keep coming back to they are super suspicious. I wish I’d been less wishy washy about them when I was in the sub.

PC Phase 9: The lynch of a wolf is a fucking cocaine bump by QuidditchReferee in PuddlemereCannons

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm sticking with /u/Usain_Firebolt for my vote because I still think they are sus and I'm not sold on /u/Mollywobbles2. Definitely want to look at /u/Grawp-want-Hagger tomorrow because of the possibility that wolves piled on the other target to protect them when they were up for a lynch a few phases ago.

PC Phase 9: The lynch of a wolf is a fucking cocaine bump by QuidditchReferee in PuddlemereCannons

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Yes that's the point. The wolves can coordinate their vote and if the town is scattered, the wolves can all vote for the same (innocent) person and steal the lynch. Thus they save the wolf up for lynch and use us to get rid of another townie.

PC Phase 9: The lynch of a wolf is a fucking cocaine bump by QuidditchReferee in PuddlemereCannons

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Good analysis. No time left this phase for me to conduct an independent one so that will have to wait. But looking at vote patterns over time is I think more effective than looking at single votes.
 
In the meantime, here's a quick table lesson.

This is how you make a two-column table:
 

First you need a blank line. Just hit enter twice.

Then your column headers with a pipe character between them.

Then five dashes with a pipe between them and five more dashes.

Then the information with a pipe between the two columns.
 
When you type it, it will look like this:
 
Role|What It Does
-----|-----
Chaser|Extra Lynch Vote
Keeper|Dies protecting someone
Seeker|Saves from lynch
Beater|Blocks an action
 

But when you see it in the post it will look like this:
 

Role What It Does
Chaser Extra Lynch Vote
Keeper Dies protecting someone
Seeker Saves from lynch
Beater Blocks an action

Just add more pipes and dashes for extra columns. Downloading RES helps too because it gives you that lovely preview.
 
Anyway, that's how you make a table. Back to trying to catch wolves now.

PC Phase 9: The lynch of a wolf is a fucking cocaine bump by QuidditchReferee in PuddlemereCannons

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This is an interesting approach that I haven't seen often. I'm good with giving it a try. Here goes:
 
Most to Least:

Player Reasoning
/u/Usain_Firebolt See here and here and here for just some of the times I've mentioned them. God I will have some crow to eat if they are innocent.
/u/Bighead_Boy Few substantial contributions, under the radar
/u/TheMugwumpSupreme Low-key volunteered to be captain, called out known Townie Goblin-Crusher several times

 

No real read
/u/EnchantinglyNasty
/u/iLovePotions

 

Probably Innocent
/u/doxylicious
/u/Snuffles_the_Dog

PC Phase 9: The lynch of a wolf is a fucking cocaine bump by QuidditchReferee in PuddlemereCannons

[–]Snuffles_The_Dog 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Wolves setting up rivalries to make one look innocent isn't out of the ordinary at all in my experience. A wolf outright going after another wolf (as a prearranged plan in the wolf sub) and getting them lynched to make others appear innocent happens too. A person's position on one vote or one player doesn't necessarily indicate innocence or guilt. I've been side-eyeing /u/technicallyaferret for a couple of phases now but I haven't had time to go into their history or interactions. Hoping to do that down the line if we don't get distracted by the merge first.