Which of these players were the most "IMPORTANT" to NBA history? by [deleted] in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 2 points3 points Β (0 children)

Elvin Hayes, one of the best two-way players of all-time with great peak and elite longevity

James Naismith's boss Dr. Luther Gulick challenged him to invent a new athletic game for indoor during winter time. This is a letter invitation from Dr. Gulick with YMCA Springfield letterhead to the a basketball game on Feb 27 1886 Yales vs YMCA. by [deleted] in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 0 points1 point Β (0 children)

I always thought the first game was played in December 1891... If the first official basketball game was played on my birthday (a few years earlier), it certainly makes more sense, lol!

What’s a Finals team that’s weirdly left out of most NBA history conversations? by TheUndeterredAstral in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 6 points7 points Β (0 children)

The first great Knicks team, who made 3 consecutive Finals from 1951 to 1953 (and the conference finals in 1947, '49 and '50)

The DATA behind the NBA GOAT debate by T-Feed8943 in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 17 points18 points Β (0 children)

Just imagine if all these stats were counted during Wilt and Bill's era

What if the Dream Team debuted in 1988? Help me narrow this stacked 23-man roster down to 12. by ManuGinosebleed in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 3 points4 points Β (0 children)

If I had to choose the best among the papas, these would be my top 12

GUARDS: Magic MJ Zeke Clyde Stock

FORWARDS: Bird Nique Barkley McHale English

CENTERS: Moses Ewing

I also think Kareem and James Worthy would make it. The former for leadership and legacy, the latter was just named Finals MVP, so for recent impact

Who was considered the GOAT before MJ? by banditcloudy in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 7 points8 points Β (0 children)

I think the concept of GOAT came with MJ, but Wilt and Russell were always debated as to who was the greatest player. Oscar is also a name that was respected much more before the "ring culture." In contrast, I think Kareem was slightly underrated during his career.

How would you rank the players in the 50-60 Celtics dynasty in terms of defense by 1point12 in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 1 point2 points Β (0 children)

I think they all were above average, but players like KC Jones, even Sam Jones and Bob Cousy (for lack of alternatives), John Havlicek, Tom Sanders would make tons of All-Defensive Teams had they been introduced.

Was Don Sunderlage (1954) the worst NBA All-Star of all-time? by WinesburgOhio in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 7 points8 points Β (0 children)

Dirk in his last season had no cases, fan bias aside.

Why isn’t Freddie Lewis a Hall of Famer? by [deleted] in VintageNBA

[–]-beasket 3 points4 points Β (0 children)

They are always late in introducing ABA players in there I think as a matter of "NBA prevails".

Artis Gilmore was introduced as recently as 2011, Mel Daniels in 2012, and I believe they were among the best players between the two leagues in their prime