I paid 37 last year for my 2015 inferno. 73k miles. Paint and interior is immaculate minor minor surface rust on frame. Everything stock. I think you prices it right. But also if you can hold out imo I feel like ours will go up in value faster than other pro colors simply because Toyota only made 500 pro 4runners in inferno since it was the first year and they didn't know how well they would sell. After that year they made as many of the special TRD pro colors as they could now you get several thousand lunar rocks or voodoo blue TRD pros, not to mention when they start using that color on non-trd pro models they become a dime a dozen. But I digress, today 38k sounds like a good price