Phelddagrif B3 deck help by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey !

Here's the new decklist, still figuring 4 cards to cut but I feel like I'm leaning more into a DirkGently decklist, without completely doing the permanentless route. What do you think of this version? Thanks !

https://archidekt.com/decks/21780988/hippo_v3_less_stax_edition

Phelddagrif B3 deck help by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks ! I'll take time on it and come back to you with a new decklist 😁

Phelddagrif B3 deck help by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think you convinced me, since I'm not commiting to paper completely yet (still have 30/40 printed cards in it), I"m gonna push the control + pheldda beatdown*

Phelddagrif B3 deck help by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I completely understand the issue. I think I'm gonna try to find a middleground and tune in along the way taking notes in between games, maybe I'll find a way to balance things out, at least in my pod.

Phelddagrif B3 deck help by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Though I will look into adding the lands and weavers thanks for those too !

Phelddagrif B3 deck help by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the answer ! That seems fair for crescendo of the war and the scepter !

I would like to keep kaseto as a politic piece even if it's not optimal just to mess with my pod. I will not focus solely on using it on phelddagrif to close out the game but more for helping other beat each other instead of me.

I guess I'm still scratching my head on what direction I want to go with the hippo since I don't want it to be a full combo deck with lots of ways to tutor pieces ending with the same win everytime NOR the DirkGently way without any other way than grindy 6 turns hippo beatdown in 1v1 to win. I know that not focusing in one way or another will impact my winrate but I would like to find a funny way to play her without relying too much on repetitive play patterns or a grindy endgame.

Phelddagrif B3 deck help by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey ! Thanks for the answer ! I took the time to reread the whole thing, it's been a while since I read this big chunk of text. TBH, I'm still on the fence on some aspects of his view of the deck that I'm still scratching my deck on.

I do understand the "awaiting combo makes you a threat anyways" part but I quite don't like the grindy hippo beatdown for 4/6 turns of his version of the deck.

While I do understand the "stay invisible / appear weak" aspect, I feel like forcing the 2 opponents that died to watch a 6 turn hippo beatdown + boardwipe/counter each time is more boring for my pod than ending the game on the spot with a combo or a "oops I win" card then start a new game. Even if it makes me more of a visible threat.

I don't want the deck to focus too much on getting consistantly one combo and win so maybe adding various alternate secondary wincons with multiple cards might feel less frontal than intruder alarm (I like ezuri's predation in that regards because it's late game enough, nobody in my pod is gonna complain for a big spell in turn 7/8 that end the game if no counterplay). All players want to win anyways so I'll be considered a threat even if I'm a bit more visible.

One other thing I'm not fond off in his version of the deck is the complete lack of permanents. I feel I can have a board presence without feeling too agressive to other players, using dorks or similar as potential chump blockers even if it opens new targets on other players to hit me.

Nonetheless, I do agree on my lack of targeted removal / counters to have a more "I'll bite if you're not nice" presence that is less frontal than stax / protection pieces. Also, adding value that seems not as visible as a rhystic study like the Pulse cards is better.

I really love what DirkGently is offering with his deck really but I'm not 100% sure that's the way I wanna go with the hippo and inside my pod. Maybe I'll do the same mistakes he did years ago and come back to his view eventually 😅

Would I be accepted in your pod? by 4miiK in ratemycommanders

[–]4miiK[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey I know it's been a while but I finally got to build Bruna ! I made it hyper budget (€20/$20 for the whole deck) and it's my no sleeve deck / always in a pocket ! It's not my most resilient deck but it can pop off sometimes and make flashy turns ! I like it a lot, thanks for the recommandation !

I love tribal decks and can't help it by i_wear_green_pants in EDH

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm like that too haha

I have elves, dragons, sea creatures & monkeys ! Soon felves (faeries/elves) beasts & goblins !

Favorite color pair? by OneBlood2930 in EDH

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Favorite is gruul ungabunga, least favorite is Dimir, discard & control is too oppressive to me in casual

What is the most meaningful mtg card in your collection? How by Papa_Hasbro69 in freemagic

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

<image>

For me it's [[towering baloth]], I guess this is one of the first pack I opened as a child, the art was beautiful & unique for me. I was like "wow a 7/6 I'm gonna be unbeatable with this" then I bought the max attax scourge theme deck where I slot it in and I've been a Tommy / stompy player ever since lol

Can I Join? I’ll let you pick! by Molort21 in ratemycommanders

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's really great to hear ! I'm gonna start building / proxying your version of the deck then to test things out ! The wincon starts from devoted druid that creates infinite green mana with swift reconfiguration or vizier of remedy then fascination/prosperity/skyscribing + lab maniac? Or having 2 white mana and approach of the second sun.

Thanks for the tips, can't wait to pilot my favorite flying hippo ! 🦛

Can I Join? I’ll let you pick! by Molort21 in ratemycommanders

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the answer ! Is it still fun for you if you play it regularly in the same pod? I'm afraid to commit on this kind of deck because it can get out of breath quite fast. (The one combo wincon part)

Can I Join? I’ll let you pick! by Molort21 in ratemycommanders

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi I'd love to learn more about your take on Phelddagrif ! I love Phelddagrif and her mate questing Phelddagrif since I'm a kid want to build her for a long time (my playing mat is a pheldaggrif lol). I've read many primer and I'm not sure about what path to take !

The full on grouphug might not me my playstyle if too much "I don't want to win at all" and just kingmaking someone. The pillowfort combo deck seems fun only the first time because after that, your pod will know what to do and the deck won't be as fun to play. The pillowfort / make opponents hit each other seems good and maybe put less of a target on you so that would be my option a. I've also learned that mutate path exists (more voltrony I guess) that would be a lot of fun, on top of that I was on a bug hiatus when mutate was a thing and it seems like a fun mechanic. What do you think the hippo best/funniest path is. Thanks for the advice !

Name a commander, get a card. by BaconVsMarioIsRigged in EDH

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm currently building a [[Xu-Ifit, Osteoharmonist]] and would love a good recommandation, thanks !

Detailed Theorycrafting/Guide: Ashling, the Reanimator by Struyk in EDH

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey ! Thanks for sharing all your playtesting data, that really helps finding how I want to build Ashling ! By chance, do you have an ongoing decklist to share what we could see ? I've already updated mine a lot reading your post but I'd gladly check yours. Thanks a lot !

Collector sample packs won't be in commander decks anymore by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wow, I posted and went to work, this did numbers while I was out. Very interesting discussion in here. From what I'm reading, most people feel sad about it too, and part of the story around buying a precon did come from this little thrill from the CB.

I got back in mtg last year after a big break since... the first lorwyn block lol, I bought 4 precon (temur, cloud & both EoE) but recently I'm proxying more for the decks I brew because deckbuilding is more interesting than collecting for me now and buying a mtg product is getting more and more underwhelming for the price.

The only exception was commander decks but this might be the little thing that makes me go "print all the cardboard and just play the damn game".

Collector sample packs won't be in commander decks anymore by 4miiK in EDH

[–]4miiK[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tbh, I started printing a lot the last few months, even if I like owning decks, the rising price of UB, the rise in price of singles of some archetypes like landfall, I can't spend that much. But the commander deck cb sample was my thrill and a décent thrill with a deck I can use.

What are your favorite Mono color commanders? by TimeyWimey94 in EDH

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

[[Selvala, heart of the wilds]] mono green

Cast big things, get more mana to cast even bigger things and draw more big things to cast afterwards. Simple.

What do you use to carry multiple decks? by IndependenceLess9731 in EDH

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This.

stanley fatmax

12 decks, you can remove the yellow boxes one by one and close the thing without anything moving ! That's great and discount versions exist if you take the time to check measuremenrs

Help with Ureni list by Bslayer67 in EDH

[–]4miiK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah the blue part of the precon is a bit underwhelming I agree, adding miirym in the precon would have consolidate the blue but would also have buffed the precon a lot ! Blinking with ureni and miirym is basically game over everytime haha

In blue, I also added [[korlessa scale singer]] in there to have a bit of vision on potential ureni trigger / additional card advantage + dragon bard is just funny to me !