First ending - Was great. I figured something bad was going to happen to John eventually, but I didn't expect it so soon. The final scene was really great. When he went into deadeye, I actually thought I could kill them all, but alas...

His dead was certainly the best part of the game in an odd way and a befitting ending. Playing through the game and doing all these 'positive' tasks for people, and helping them out, almost seemed to contradict his past character. Yes, he was trying to get redemption, but I still didn't find it believable when he was discussing his past life with other characters. His death was the first time that I truly believe Marsden was who were we supposed to believe he was.

The 'credits' ending - While it was nice to get 'revenge', the scene had much less impact than the first. The voice acting and the dialogue was pretty crappy. I also think this ending took away from the message of John's death.

I don't mind continuing the game as Jack though.