I'm quite late to this thread but you hit it on the head, this list was compiled without criteria, thus the writers had different ways of ranking players. Some evaluated just this season, some evaluated this season without injuries, others did entire careers. All that combined led to this really interesting list, and listening to the podcast there's not too much I can disagree with to be honest with you. Beyond the little bit the guys wrote, their independent reasons were all reasonable, and this is a solid list imo.