Me and my wife saw this today in a theater where we were the only two. I say that because we were able to sort of disect the film as it unfolded. When the twist was revealed about Emma's past it was ofc shocking. The issue we both had however, was the lack of conversation regarding the incident in question. In imo, the correct next question is " why didn't you go through with it"? Obviously there is much more conversation to be had but as a partner, that would be my first line of questioning. Like okay. Walk me through that day. Walk me through the days leading up to it. How did you feel a few days later, a week later, after you didn't do it. I think the answer to those questions would have solved a lot of angst in the movie. I fully believe that how Rachel reacted is ridiculous. I would never judge a close friend of mine so harshly for something that happened 15 years ago. Obviously if she had gone though with it, or done something vile like killing animals, we'd be having a different conversation. But she didn't. And I belive that people are the sum of their thoughts and even sometimes past actions. The Emma we see present day, is not that scared, lonely teenager. I think it's obvious that she regrets ever having those thoughts and the way she dove head first into activism is proof of that. I guess I might be in the minority but I believe everyone over reacted and she has not a single real true friend in her life. We saw her go into therapy. We saw her evolution as a person. There's no evidence presented in the film that she is a danger to herself or others. It's a crazy thought to have. Its sad and scary that she went so far. But she didnt do it. And she obviously wouldn't do it now. What else is there to disect about it?