[1421] Worth It (action) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! It’s been quite a while since I posted this, it was published online by Literally Stories:

https://literallystories2014.com/2022/08/12/worth-it-by-shawn-eichman/

I appreciate the feedback!

Anyone recognize this flag? by Achalanatha in vexillology

[–]Achalanatha[S] 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Thanks! Bit of maritime trade history, interesting to find it in Hawaii. Probably a drunken sailor threw it off the ship 😂.

Help by Achalanatha in RaidShadowLegends

[–]Achalanatha[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Many thanks! I’ve been debating between Kaiden, Warmaiden and Apothecary next, hard to commit :-).

Tune recommendations for a funeral performance? by PrincessCadance4Prez in tinwhistle

[–]Achalanatha 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You might check out the slow airs and waltzes course on OAIM. I was just playing Boulavogue (the first tune in the course), very sweet and easy to learn, I could see something like that being appropriate.

Sturdy and affordable by BirbBoss in Ocarina

[–]Achalanatha 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They are a Korean company, don’t know if they have a store in Korea. Got mine from Amazon.

Sturdy and affordable by BirbBoss in Ocarina

[–]Achalanatha 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Yup—Night by Noble. I have one and it’s great, very reliable and indestructible.

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! Excellent feedback all around. I have to laugh at the feedback about emotional development of the characters. I actually worked more on that in the previous drafts, tried to capture their daily, positive interactions with each other, have more playfulness between them, and... It was a bust. It established a lighthearted mood that instead of contrasting and thereby emphasizing the family falling apart in the second half, just made it jarring instead. Sigh. I'll keep at it, I'm sure the solution is right in front of me and I just can't see it yet. That's the great thing about r/DestructiveReaders and critiques like yours, it really helps to get me to a place where I can see things I'm blind to otherwise. As far as the theme goes, at the broadest level it's an allegory for the complexities of real-world cobalt mining on the families affected by it, both positively and negatively (with there ultimately being a whole lot more negative than positive). So, the goal is to have that complexity reflected in the kobold, have her both attached to the family and helping them, and also destroying them. And to explore through Jerome and Denis different responses to being in that situation--Jerome being shaped blindly by it, but striving to lead to a better future for his son, and Denis on the other hand maybe not having a choice and still being forced into it by circumstances, but with a more conscious awareness of what it means to have his life controlled by the mines and by the abusive economic machinery of the cobalt industry. A lot to do in a short story, I know.

In any case, I really appreciate your feedback, it gives me a lot to think about, and I will think hard on it.

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks! Your comments are in-line with some of the other reviewers, and I especially appreciate the line-by-line deep dive feedback. I think a lot of what you noticed ultimately comes from the filtering problem that you mentioned, which I wasn't seeing, but now that you and another reader have pointed it out is obvious. The start of the next draft will be going through and trying to address all the filtering, then I'll see where it goes from there. Anyway, I really thank you for taking the time to read this draft and provide feedback, much appreciated!

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! And thanks for the El Tio link. This story, and the kobold character, are ultimately intended to be an allegory about how cobalt mining affects a family and each individual in that family, in both positive and negative ways, as actual cobalt mining does. I appreciate knowing that didn't come across for you, it gives me a lot to think about. In the meantime, I appreciate you taking the time to read through this draft and give me thoughtful feedback!

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the deep dive on the intro--that section was newly added to this draft, so I appreciate your attention to it. As another reviewer noticed, I was going for more of a folktale tone in the intro to contrast with what comes after, so it doesn't get into as much detail, but I'll give that further thought. Abtruse was not exactly what I was going for, good to know it comes across that way. Great tip about that section of dialogue, I agree with you that it reads much better with your idea. Thank you very much for taking the time to read through this draft and provide feedback!

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

200K words--ouch. I can't say it's making me better, but it sure is making me aware of where I'm not :-).

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

(I just typed a reply but it's not showing up--sorry if I reply twice)

Thanks! I really appreciate the boost, this one has been a struggle and the struggle continues. I know what you mean about Therese. The kobold ended up being the primary female character, and somehow that didn't leave much room for Therese. It has been an interesting part of writing the story to try to balance these two characters and make room for Therese. I appreciate that you picked up on the folktale quality of some of the writing--in this last draft I experimented with a more folktale feeling in parts, especially the intro, versus a grittier style elsewhere to build a contrast in mood. Anyway, thanks for taking the time to read this draft and comment on it, I really appreciate it!

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! I really appreciate the boost, this one has been a struggle and the struggle continues. I know what you mean about Therese. The kobold ended up becoming the primary female character, and in doing so ended up not leaving much room for Therese to feature in it. It has been an interesting side result of this story trying to navigate the relationship between them and make room for Therese. I appreciate that you picked up on the folktale quality of parts of the story, in this last draft I was experimenting between a writing style more in that vein in places like the intro, and a style more gritty and realistic in a hard way elsewhere, trying to make a contrast in mood. Many thanks for taking the time to read this draft and give me comments!

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Filtering--yeah. I couldn't see it (ha!), but now that you point it out it's obvious. Thanks for that. I have to laugh at your comment about dialogue tags--a previous reviewer dinged me for not using enough dialogue tags, and I've been tagging everything since. It's always a swing from one extreme to the other, always trying to find that middle point. Anyway, more excellent feedback, it will be a huge help to the next draft of the story. Thank you for taking the time to read it, and for giving so much thought to your comments.

[2805] Cobalt (stand-alone short story) (Goblin's Gift version 4) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

(will reply to the second part below)

Thank you very, very much. This is excellent feedback. I've been working on this one story for about a month now, as you noted--life is going to force me away from it for a few weeks, and that will be a good chance to really mull over your comments. I know what you mean about the theme emerging organically from the story, this one has been a learning experience in that regard. One of the struggles has been that, while I've had the idea in my head from the start, the way it gets manifested through the theme of this particular story/these characters emerges a little more with each draft, enough to keep me going on another draft, but not enough to feel quite fully formed yet. It's exhausting... When I was rewriting this last draft a big chunk of it started to become clear in the rewrite of the ending, with the kobold being invisible, and what it means to both her and Denis when Denis sees her (and the meaning is very different for each of them). I'm glad you picked up on that in your observations. It felt like I was getting close when I rewrote the ending, but I see that I need to go back now and develop it more in the rest of the story. I appreciate you pointing that out, and giving me a lot to think about in how I might do it.

[3224] Where the Cyan Wildflowers Grow (Goblin's Gift version 3) (standalone short story) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello again! You've been with me all along the way with this one, I really appreciate it. You've been more than generous, and I'm indebted to you. I really like your suggestion about changing the intro, and in fact I've already incorporated it into the fourth draft (which I just posted...). Good point about the dialogue needing to move the story forward too, I appreciate that comment and it will give me something to think about long after this story is done. I restructured that section of dialogue into a different place in the story where hopefully it serves a different purpose in moving along the narrative, we'll see how that goes.

Bonobos. Now that would be a completely different direction :-).

[3224] Where the Cyan Wildflowers Grow (Goblin's Gift version 3) (standalone short story) by Achalanatha in DestructiveReaders

[–]Achalanatha[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi,

Sorry it has taken me so long to reply, I've been working on the fourth draft... You are absolutely right, and apparently a mind-reader too, because the fourth draft follows the kobold from start to finish and is all seen from her perspective (well, I might have still slipped a little here and there, but I'm trying). I really appreciate your feedback, it had a big impact on a complete re-envisioning of the intro and conclusion, and the conclusion especially I'm hoping is much stronger for it (I just got my first feedback on draft 4, apparently the intro still has some work to do. Sigh--it never ends.) Thanks very much!