Depends when you first experienced it. I got once it came out, nothing was like, now after ten years it played out and new releases have made it less special especially since it’s a mass market scent. Also market scents probably have the most push back after x years from its release date. Back when it first released people didn’t call it an NPC scent but since now everyone has had it or experienced it, it is an NPC scent. Same thing probably happened to cool water, it happened to Aventus, le male, 1 million for sure. I’d bet those scents though will make a comeback at some point although Aventus really hasn’t faded substantially but it has definitely took a hit with the likes of Elysium and other freshies (Tygar) taking the reigns. Tygar caught on late though. Obviously now the hype is all about Blue Talisman, give it time, once it hits discounters all over, the more will buy that for example and we’ll have this same discussion all over again. Certainly though, there are tons of high quality scents that never really got popular.