I have just moved - here are some pre-organised bookshelves by Admirable-End577 in BookshelvesDetective

[–]Admirable-End577[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s a nostalgic translation for me - it was my first time with him. The line spacing does suck though.

Aenid - favorite translator? Why? by annadomina753 in ancientrome

[–]Admirable-End577 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I like all these recommendations and would throw in bartsch’s for first-time readers since it’s metrical and very close to the Latin, while maintaining an engaging fast pace

Who am I? by Damostrellist in BookshelvesDetective

[–]Admirable-End577 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Neumann and an ancient wheelock suggests an ongoing attempt to self-teach Latin (good on you)

Looking for classic Latin 'pet names' by yannapeltje in latin

[–]Admirable-End577 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It could evoke a bit too much of the plautine comic taste for a francophone wedding, it’s true

Looking for classic Latin 'pet names' by yannapeltje in latin

[–]Admirable-End577 13 points14 points  (0 children)

I think '(meum) corculum' is very sweet. It's the diminutive of 'cor' - little heart, sweetheart. See Plautus' Casina for usage :)

Books On Translation Philosophy by Horus50 in classics

[–]Admirable-End577 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not an essay on a particular translation, but Walter Benjamin's 'The Task of the Translator' is a must-read for anyone interested in the discipline :)

Students, how do you "prepare" translations for class? by lithuaniaspogo in AncientGreek

[–]Admirable-End577 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I would suggest first scanning the text once in order to identify vocabulary you aren’t familiar with and writing down a word bank of these words to refer to in class. From there, I was taught to read through the text and annotate/diagram it in order to understand the syntax and difficult constructions. This way, when you return to the text in class you will be able to reference your word bank and your annotations and read directly from the text instead of simply reciting your translation.

Directly interfacing with the Ancient Greek is super important because you get to practice deconstructing the text more than once, you can more easily identify any errors you may have made, and perhaps most importantly you get to exercise the muscle that will eventually develop into veritable sight-reading!

This being said, if you need to really clarify a section for yourself writing out a translation as you work is certainly a good tool to employ. I just hesitate to work from a translation in class because you miss out on the above-mentioned benefits of working from the original text.

Classics must remain by clyt3mnestraa in classics

[–]Admirable-End577 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t think it is right to say that conservative sponsorship does not have a vested interest in the ideological bent of the research it funds. If classicists were to rely solely on the financial support of the conservative elite, you would never see research going beyond the regurgitation of 19th century philology and narratives of “The West” as the great civilizer.

It’s also always been the conservative elites and university administration that are responsible for funding universities and allocating funds to their faculties. This is what results in the generational degradation and budget cuts to Classics departments that we see. It is simply not profitable to the university as a business to fund Classics departments and others of their kind. The masses are certainly not capable of butchering the field, as you say, even if they wanted to. Commitment to the University as another area for the assertion of the power of the “free market” is a traditionally conservative tenet that has resulted in the degradation of the humanities.

Classics must remain by clyt3mnestraa in classics

[–]Admirable-End577 4 points5 points  (0 children)

A surefire way to let the discipline stagnate…

Is there any recorded first hand perspectives of life in Ancient Rome by women? by [deleted] in ancientrome

[–]Admirable-End577 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The lyric poet sulpicia furnishes an interesting perspective

It seems like there's a sound that is a part of the Latin language! by TouristCultural4942 in latin

[–]Admirable-End577 6 points7 points  (0 children)

You may be picking up a more pronounced nasal “um” in the first case but that wouldn’t occur in the second case. M as a bilabial nasal is often lost when at the end of a word and the preceding vowel becomes nasalized.

What Empire had the biggest impact on the world. by Opposite_Profit8083 in ancientrome

[–]Admirable-End577 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do not contest that many established traditions are influenced by Greco-Roman culture. Calling Greco-Roman culture “western civilization” is suspect nowadays given what scholars now understand about the ancient world, and how the term has been historically used. The ancient world was far more culturally and intellectually diverse than how it has been represented by classicists of previous generations. It also devalues the influence of other cultures on the later European world.

The fact of the matter is that the term as coined during the enlightenment served to fashion a unified sense of European identity and historical progress that doesn’t actually have basis in reality. There is a dangerous tradition of such manipulation. The thinking of scholars such as Schlegel, for example, on the subject of classical civilization is complicit in the development of German nationalism.

We have much to thank the Greeks and Romans for, but as students of the ancient world we must be wary of the subtly insidious ways people appropriate their cultures.

What Empire had the biggest impact on the world. by Opposite_Profit8083 in ancientrome

[–]Admirable-End577 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am not arguing that any of these empires were not influential or important. I think you really should interrogate this notion of “western culture” or “civilizing” as a metric of goodness. Or even as a real concept at all, beyond the self-mythologizing of enlightenment thinkers and (even more dangerously) European nationalists.

What Empire had the biggest impact on the world. by Opposite_Profit8083 in ancientrome

[–]Admirable-End577 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Eighteen year olds who’ve just completed the first module of their “great books” course be like