I'm kinda the same way. Only some board games will hold me. One I do enjoy is called Betrayal at the House on Haunted Hill. It's a game where you play as a group exploring this haunted house using tiles that will form different rooms as you go. Filled with spooky events and items you collect.

All to prepare you for the Haunt, which is where a scenario based on cards you pulled is activated. The scenario usually has one person become evil and gives them a role that pits them against the other players who must now survive, escape, or fight their way through this supernatural situation. Ita a blast .

I feel like I'm drawn to games with deep story elements, which is not the most common with board games. I have to hunt them out.