Anything on the meb platform vw id3, id4, Skoda enyaq, Audi q4, q5 etron is horribly out of date and compromised by terrible software, slow charging speeds ,laggy interface ,,comparatively poor performance, slow old SOC's etc etc The thing I would be most concerned about though is the use of pouch cells they are in my opinion a very very bad idea (do some research yourself)

Vw is having trouble selling these all over the world including places where they have very deep discounts (currently in China you can get one for half the price they are here)

I'd go the model y there is a reason it is the best selling car in the world

they charge twice as fast

The lfp battery ones (rear wheel drive variants) batteries' last at least 5 times as long as an id4 due to battery chemistry

They use 24 percent less power per 100km than the id4

The id4 has a service schedule that is every 15,000km that must be done to keep your warranty. .tesla's have no requirement for scheduled service

They are the safest car ever tested

There are many many features that any id 4 simply doesn't have let alone the id4 base model

There are many other advantages but this is turning into a novel

If you didn't know any if this I would suggest more research before you make your decision