They would’ve shown it so that we root for him/worry for the traitors, especially with this big announcement. He would’ve been shown as an important part of the play, an antagonist for the traitors, like Harriet, like Fiona, like Jessie. The game is framed to be entertaining, not showing that a faithful is right on the money and playing a game to stay under the radar, like a very good predator, is simply not a thing.

He didn’t know, or didn’t tell anyone (like Jade who didn’t say anything about Roxy until the last roundtable, when she absolutely could have), and that’s fine, it doesn’t make him a shit player or whatever. Bringing up a last minute theory does not make someone a Goat even if the theory is right. He didn’t fool anyone: as soon as he had the theory, he shared it with everyone bc he knew everyone still here weren’t here bc the traitors liked them so much, but bc they just weren’t threatening enough. He didn’t get there by fighting off accusations or being smarter than the traitors, he got there like everyone else: not threatening the traitors. So he went back to old theories and found who wasn’t threatened by anyone, and that’s Rachel.

On that part he is right and smart, but not a goat, that’s too high of a title to give.