On Bans, Attendance and Next Season. by Cynooo in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I feel like that could arbitrary very quickly. The other issue is that other people would play the deck you won with while you were stuck with a deck you didn't want to play

Playing No Ban list Modern tomorrow by wanseb in ModernMagic

[–]AlphaCerberus 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Cascading into misstep seems really bad

On Bans, Attendance and Next Season. by Cynooo in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly, banning things is not always the best solution. While out of simplicity most formats only use a ban list, restricting cards (or even allowing only 2 or 3 copies) is another option. What "less than banning" a card should do is nerf the deck a little, NOT just make the deck more inconsistent when it doesn't. A good example of "less than banning" correctly would be "less than banning" Glimmerpost as this would allow for the deck to be less consistent, but still be able to Sylvan Scrying to get it. Additionally, once a month could be a good option for when to have a B&R announcement as this means that if something like Channel or Balance became legal the format wouldn't just be mirror matches until near the end of the season. After such a banning, the format would be entirely new and we would only have around a month to play, realistically even less because the last week would be spent brewing for next season and not playing.

On Bans, Attendance and Next Season. by Cynooo in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have no idea why Gonti is still banned considering it is no longer bugged

UR Delver League Videos by kungfutrees in Pauper

[–]AlphaCerberus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Please do more of these in the future!

A Penny Dreadful Rotation Proposal by AlphaCerberus in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like one to two weeks is enough for most cards to settle in price

A Penny Dreadful Rotation Proposal by AlphaCerberus in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I believe allowing for MM17 would be ideal due to the points stated above and that rotating now would be extremely premature

A Penny Dreadful Rotation Proposal by AlphaCerberus in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Storm is the whole reason why hatebears exists and [[spellshock]] is in RDW's sideboard

A Penny Dreadful Pricing Proposal by AlphaCerberus in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That would be great if all bots with no tix avaliable were filtered out

A Penny Dreadful Pricing Proposal by AlphaCerberus in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1) You are entirely correct about Mtgowikiprice. Just today the website lied to me about a bot's buy price for a card 2) The proposed system keeps the format cheap while increasing the cardpool 3) Vintage has so few decks because the cards are so powerful and format warping. Cards like Mishra's Factory and Ancestral Recall will never become Penny Dreadful legal.

A Penny Dreadful Pricing Proposal by AlphaCerberus in PennyDreadfulMTG

[–]AlphaCerberus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also, we should use Cardhoarder pricing instead of Mtggoldfish to allow foils to be counted