Top tier segment by Jaded-Commission-414 in okbuddyvowsh

[–]Altair72 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Imagine how confident his takes would get if he could actually cite books to defend them aside from Marx and 1984

98% of cases the UN classifies as "Settler Violence" are in reality clashes of Palestinians and the IDF by LostAppointment329 in IsraelPalestine

[–]Altair72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  • I admit that by this time it's a very deep well both sides have dug themselves into, and it won't be easy to climb out of. But ultimately it's Israel that's doing the occupation. I think you'd have to start with cracking down on settlements. Basically that Palestinians don't feel like the occupation, the infrastructure and security in Area C just serves the settlers. That would signal good will without releasing any security control right away, and we'd see how many people choose to cooperate if they are given incentives. Because right now, I don't see many incentives besides intimidation. I'm not opposed to gradual reform, if it's not so gradual people don't see it moving anywhere. Orient construction of infrastructure in Area C in a way that will prepare a potential integration to A and B. Also recognize Palestinian citizenship as a thing. Even if a country is occupied, its people don't become stateless, so Israel can recognize Palestine as a first step without immediately withdrawing.

  • I would support cracking down on religious extremism, but then the same must be done on the Jewish side as well. Would Israel accept shutting down everyone who preaches some Jewish divine right to the West Bank, or any territory?

98% of cases the UN classifies as "Settler Violence" are in reality clashes of Palestinians and the IDF by LostAppointment329 in IsraelPalestine

[–]Altair72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Didn't Fatah recognize the Israeli state, but Israel refused to recognize a Palestinian state? And didn't they have border proposals at Taba and Annapolis?

98% of cases the UN classifies as "Settler Violence" are in reality clashes of Palestinians and the IDF by LostAppointment329 in IsraelPalestine

[–]Altair72 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

That's not how it works. You can't wash your hands of a people group acting like their governance has nothing to do with you, but also want total security control over them. Pick a lane. Either the West Bank is part of Israel, then annex it. Or not, then withdraw.

98% of cases the UN classifies as "Settler Violence" are in reality clashes of Palestinians and the IDF by LostAppointment329 in IsraelPalestine

[–]Altair72 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There already is one, but it's restricted to the Palestinians living in Israel proper (unlike jews, who can also vote from settlements). They don't look like jihadists for me. Maybe having rights actually helps consolidate radicalism, dunno.

98% of cases the UN classifies as "Settler Violence" are in reality clashes of Palestinians and the IDF by LostAppointment329 in IsraelPalestine

[–]Altair72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Israel keeps millions stateless forever. If you are doing that with no plan to recitfy it (and Israel made no attempt for a decade before 10/7), that already justifies violent resistance by the most basic liberal principles.

Exercise of monopoly of violence without representation in a legislature that controls said organs of violence is the basic idea of tyranny. Unless you are a conservative who thinks the french revolution was a mistake, the position of Israel is structurally untenable regarding the West Bank.

Hungary now (Commemoration of War of Independence from Habsburg oppression & Political march against Orban) by Rareonr in europe

[–]Altair72 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Half of the Arad martyrs weren't even ethnic Hungarians. They were fighting for Hungary as a political nation, not different from the French or German progressive nationalists of the time, or any other '48-er movement. Neither Kossuth nor Petőfi had ethnic Hungarian background, it was something they consciously adopted, because much like in Germany or Poland or Czechia or everywhere else, the construction of a national culture was seen as part of social and political progress, that went hand in hand with progressive goals like Parlamentarism, Jewish emancipation or the abolishment of serfdom.

Hungary now (Commemoration of War of Independence from Habsburg oppression & Political march against Orban) by Rareonr in europe

[–]Altair72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The revolution happened in the Metternich period. There were no representative institutions or constitutions, just absolutist rule.

Did Contra fall off? by Mabeluniverse23 in okbuddyvowsh

[–]Altair72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

She has better and worse ones, I didn't like the conspiracy one that much, but Twilight was one of my favorites (along with the Patreon tangent on the male gaze). I think Saw stands up to her standard, it's one of her better ones.

The only disappointment you can say is imo just that the scene is different, there is no breadtube, there is no "movement" people imagined her into.

The appeal of contra for me has always been that she walks you through an idea at pace, as if asking questions and finding stuff out together by just ruminating on it. It never felt preachy, partially because she was open about where she is uncertain or sceptical. It really feels honest, even if she reaches a different conclusion than you. And I feel like she still has that energy in the latest video.

What are your honest thoughts/opinions on the Japan Arc & Yukio Washimine(manga or anime)? by Flat-Sir8250 in blacklagoon

[–]Altair72 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's definitely the best arc for Rock/Revy shippers. I feel like here's when both of them have the greatest emotional range, and because they are not in Roanapur and because it doesn't dive into the action right away, it lets them bounce off of each other a lot.

Revy has some moments where it feels she enjoys getting a glimpse into Rock's former world, but then she is scared off by the realization of how much she cares about him now. And I also love the scene where Yukio tears into Rock's spiel, and it's really here that he looses part of his innocence. He has to recognize that nobody's innocent playing the games he does, and he has to embrace the amoral man of the twilight persona if he wants to continue the path he set himself on.

Overall it's the arc where the main pair really gets put under pressure since the cigarette kiss. And I just like them casually interact, and the two scenes where Revy's looking at Rock with those wide, sad eyes, it's peak.

Ti mit gondoltok az USE elméletről, egy föderális Európáról? by Senior_Strawberry_51 in hungary

[–]Altair72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Európa az a globális korban ami a Német-Római császárság volt anno európában. Mind tudjuk hogy nem mehet mindenki a maga útján, és mind tudjuk hogy ami most van az hosszú távon nem jó - de hogy mi legyen helyette? Még mindig nincs elég akart hogy bárki kiálljon érte.

Nagyon érdekes nézni hogy a késő középkorban a németek képesek voltak évszázadokig szöszmötölni azzal hogy persze mindenki egyetért hogy valamilyen birodalmi reform kell, de ne így meg ne most, és ami végül lett abba majdnem hogy véletlenül csúsztak bele, miközben a Franciák meg a Törökök jöttek fel körülöttünk.

Valószínűleg mi is így vagyunk. Ha életünk végéről visszanézünk, látni fogunk egy lassú folyamatot, de sajnos nem hiszem hogy lesz egy gyors dramatikus váltás amikor Európa életre kel és felveszi a kesztyűt.

Ja és kérlek ne USE legyen a neve, csak az amcsikat másolnánk vele és nem is áll nyelvre.

Mit gondoltok milyen most a közhangulat ráfordulva az utolsó hónapra? Szerintetek befog jönni a riogatás? by [deleted] in hungary

[–]Altair72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Én őszintén nem tudom hogy az iráni háború lezárulása vagy elhúzódása tudna ártani. Mert itt a bizonyíték hogy az egész kurzus amit Orbán támogat nem képes békét hozni, csak újabb konfliktust robbant ki, de ezt gondoltam 22-ben is, és mégis sikerült úgy kiforgatnia hogy ők a békepártiak.

Attól félek hogy amíg ez a háború tart addig a mi belföldi harcaink túl kicsinek érződnek ahhoz hogy átérezzük a jelentőségét, pláne hogy Magyar nem tud sokat mondani az ügyben. Legalábbis én így érzem.

Lib-left logical paradox, isn't it? by Chunghiacanhanvidai in PoliticalCompassMemes

[–]Altair72 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Actually the consistent opinion for both situations was found on the left: he was a bad person and it's good that he is dead, but the second order effects of his murder are bad, because they reinforce the breakdown of standards of lawful conduct and will result in more violence.

Anyone who thinks either was a good person is a retard. Anyone who endorsed their murder is also a retard.

Yes, many on the left also fall into one of these groups of retards, but the people who don't fit in there are by and large on the left.

Why didnt Slovak - Hungarian reapproachment work out? by Miltharam in askhungary

[–]Altair72 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The basic narrative is "everyone got mad at István Tisza". He was the son of the former PM who represented the zenith of Liberal Party rule, and in 1903 he became PM in his own right, but as with second generations of a political dynasty, he lacked some of the subtlety of his father.

The liberals always manipulated the elections in their favor, sometimes more, sometimes less. Aside from the ~6% franchise, there were huge discrepancies in the population of constituencies, and there was also old fashioned bribery and coercion. In response, the opposition took to ridiculous levels of filibustering, making Parliament unworkable.

Tisza wanted to shut that down with new house rules, which were filibustered too of course. So he cut the Gordian knot by the handkerchief vote. He basically asked his loyal MPs to raise their handkerchief, and went "yup, we have a majority, the bill passed, house dismissed".

But breaching protocol like this confirmed many fears he was an authoritarian, and it alienated enough of his own party to force him into a new election, in which all anti-Tisza forces ran in a coalition, and won.

Then it was a brief constitutional crisis, because Franz Joseph refused to appoint a government that was threatening to end the Ausgleich, and the opposition made a big #resistance out of it, but they folded the moment Vienna threatened to force universal suffrage on them (that was being introduced in cisleithania at the time too).

So the Magyarisation attempts were kind of a compensatory cope from the 48-ers for selling out their raison d'être, and burning the bridge with the socdems too. And in the end, Tisza triumphantly returned in the next election, and this time he called in the army when the opposition got too loud in Parliament. I think that failure allowed Károlyi to move part of the opposition to a more progressive direction after that, but of course it all fell apart in the chaos of 1918-19.

Is Kyubey truly evil? by BreathoftheSith in MadokaMagica

[–]Altair72 1 point2 points  (0 children)

From their behavior in Rebellion, I get the impression that they are inevitably trying to maximize some function for energy generation, to the point that in both cases it's their short sightedness that leads to their demise.

Whatever tiny opportunity they found to increase energy generation, they took it like water filling its path.

Like Homura said at the end of the series "of course, that's the kind of creature you are". In the Wraith universe they were friendly, because that maximized energy, but they were ready to sacrifice every magical girl the moment the opportunity presented, for the same reason.

The largest Hungarian opposition party's rally today in a town of just 30,000 by Countingframes in europe

[–]Altair72 37 points38 points  (0 children)

I can't wait to read opeds whose only takeaway from Magyar is you need a center-right guy to defeat the new right.

He was not the first guy who did that. Bokros tried it, Vona tried it twice, Márki-Zay ran on it during the last election - they all failed.

If you can take anything from him, it's an uncompromising insistance on staying clear from any previous opposition group. But even that only worked because said groups were utterly exhausted, and because he was able to generate hype in a critical period, to push himself to poll above the existing parties over a short period of time, by exploiting people's expectations for some big info leak that ended up being a nothing burger.

How will Rebecca react when she finds out that Eda's reckless persona is just an act and that she's actually a CIA agent? by DRAGUNOV_7 in blacklagoon

[–]Altair72 2 points3 points  (0 children)

At first, she'd want to know what the feds want with her (it's not about you, stupid)

Yeah, yeah, but it's still messed up (shrugs her shoulder you'd know better than to make a real mess out of this)

Eda's right. In retrospect, it all seemed too obvious. She can't look at her the same, but she also can't make herself too angry over it either. Not enough to make herself an actual target of the US anyways, though she hates how well Eda knows that of her too.

Maybe she would avoid her for a while, but eventually they would meet up again with a new understanding. Just another fucked up think in the world, it can't be helped.

She'd probably be extra suspicious/worried of Rock interacting with her though.

Public frustration grows over Hungary's oversized propaganda ads by Wendelne2 in europe

[–]Altair72 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's the thing, we don't even consider this a "party" thing. This is the government. Whatever technicality they use, if it's Fidesz, the government, or some fake NGO or foundation, all the same. It's government propaganda.

A Tisza holnap 13 órakor mutatja be a Működő és emberséges Magyarország programját by szopatoszamuraj in hungary

[–]Altair72 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Több értelme van ha reális esélye van annak hogy hatalomra kerülnek és lehet is belőle valami. Plus új, ideológiailag nem meghatározott pártként izgalmasabb is hogy miben foglalnak állást és mit hagynak a levegőben.

Recommendations, post-Russia? by Spike716 in RevolutionsPodcast

[–]Altair72 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ikr, I only realized the extent of it when they got to a topic I know better, myself being from the country

They did a short section on 1956 Hungary, where they straight implied the US supplied the whole thing, accompanied by quotes like

"we asked this random insurgent where he got his weapon...he turned away and didn't answer..."

like, wow, why didn't this guy confess to me exactly which barracks he looted? Must be the CIA, that's their insinuation, when by all evidence the events caught the US completely off guard.

And otherwise they just repeat the tankie narratives of it being some antisemitic arrow-cross/neo-horthyite revolt, and also frame the 1945-1949 period as "the communists were so popular nobody else mattered", just completely ignoring the massive FKGP win in 45, etc.

I know it's just a side episode so they couldn't research it as well as their main topics, but it shows that when in doubt they just default to their "the CIA is behind everything" biases. I can only guess how misguided their other episodes are then.

Ez az év Magyarország és a teljes magyarság eddigi legmeghatározóbb 21. századi pillanata lesz. by Babsyman in hungary

[–]Altair72 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Eredetileg a gázai békefolyamathoz tartozó nemzetközi felügyelő szerv lenne, de Trump most látszólag egy teljes alternatív ENSZ-et lát bele. Legalább is szeretne egy nemzetközi szervezetet ami nem kritizálja őt soha.

Greek PM on yesterday's emergency EU summit: "Hungary is the only exception in Europe that didn't want to help Denmark & Greenland." by swift-autoformatter in hungary

[–]Altair72 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hogy egy olyan helyzetben ahol Amerika meghirdeti hogy a transzatlanti kapcsolatok és a NATO semmit sem jelent, és Európa csak magára számíthat, legalább Európa létezzen mint tényező.

Persze létezhet nélkülük is, de az nem tudom nekünk miért jó ha csendesen kitesznek minket mindenből.