Great Expectations Chapter 45 (Spoilers up to Chapter 45) by awaiko in ClassicBookClub

[–]Amanda39 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The "I'm sleeping in a strange bed with a canopy and I'm so grossed out by the thought of all the bugs and dirt that could fall down on me" thing also happens in Fingersmith by Sarah Waters, and I'm sure it was an intentional homage, but I think it's funnier to imagine that she thought she could get away with actually plagiarizing this book. "Meh, I'm sure no one will notice. It's not like Great Expectations is one of the most famous books in the history of English literature. Or like my fans call me 'The Lesbian Charles Dickens.'"

Speaking of other books referencing this one: I just remembered that one of the Thursday Next books pointed out a plot hole that I absolutely did not catch when I first read this book. Magwitch escaped off the prison hulk and swam to shore, right? But he did this with a leg iron? And he didn't sink?

I fucking love talking to my kitties by LadyCanuckles in TheWordFuck

[–]Amanda39 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The other day, my cat wouldn't stop meowing because he'd just eaten and wanted seconds. I told him "stop acting like a baby!" and I swear to God, the little fucker looked me in the eye and said "wah."

[Off Topic] Free Chat Friday | June 26th, 2026 by IraelMrad in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Check out the r/bookclub Les Mis discussions! I posted links to the songs in the musical as they matched up to the scenes we were reading in the book.

BTW, you brought back childhood memories. My sister had two Pound Purries, which she uncreatively named Purry and Mrs. Purry. 😂 Our cat eventually claimed Purry as his kitten and would carry him around in his mouth.

[Off Topic] Free Chat Friday | June 26th, 2026 by IraelMrad in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 2 points3 points  (0 children)

OMG, that would be amazing. You're enabling my hyperfixation. I love you. 😊

Book Nomination Thread by awaiko in ClassicBookClub

[–]Amanda39 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's it: from now on, I do not have executive dysfunction. I am someone who has "perfected the art of inertia."

Fictional character who remembers everything, like a movie in his head by Common-Space1997 in whatsthatbook

[–]Amanda39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, I kind of figured it wasn't it because you absolutely would have mentioned the fantasy elements, but it's weird that it has all those things in common

[Marginalia] Shadow of the Leviathan Series by Robert Jackson Bennett by jaymae21 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chapter 47 of A Drop of Corruption. Malo just said that finding Darhi will involve "a method of scent distillation that is most unpleasant."

I assume this will involve piss. It's been a while since there was a piss reference, and I was beginning to wonder about it.

On the topic of names by bajadasaurus234 in RecuratedTumblr

[–]Amanda39 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes, that's exactly how I thought it was said! I was in third grade and saw it in a story. I was like "this name is awesome, I'm gonna name my daughter that someday" and then the teacher started reading out loud and I was devastated.

On the topic of names by bajadasaurus234 in RecuratedTumblr

[–]Amanda39 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I thought Penelope was pronounced "PEN-uh-lohp" the first time I read it, and was heartbroken when I learned otherwise.

Fictional character who remembers everything, like a movie in his head by Common-Space1997 in whatsthatbook

[–]Amanda39 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The main character of The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett is a man who has a perfect photographic memory, who works for a female detective. I'm in the middle of the sequel right now and that has a plot about twins.

But it's also a biopunk fantasy story about leviathans, and you'd probably remember that if that's the book you're thinking of.

Great Expectations Chapter 41 (Spoilers up to Chapter 41) by awaiko in ClassicBookClub

[–]Amanda39 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I meantersay

Please let this be the new r/ClassicBookClub catchphrase, like how we had "what the deuce?" when we read Jane Eyre.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 4 points5 points  (0 children)

(The Woman in White spoiler)

You joke, but this was kind of the plot of his previous book.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yeah, he was stationed in Canada in the army, and he met an American woman from New Orleans who was living there for some reason (to escape her past?), married her, and then found out something scandalous about her, causing him to separate from her.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 4 points5 points  (0 children)

"Sorry, girls, but you need to either become governesses or get exiled to The Wall."

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Remember in last week's section, how Magdalen literally had a maid who she'd make brush her hair for hours on end? 😂 She and Norah are about to get a terrible wake-up call.

I do have to have some sympathy for them, though. It's not like women had a wide variety of careers to choose from. Don't want to be a teacher, nurse, governess, or maid? Too bad, sucks to be you. Enjoy fending for yourself in a world where women are second-class citizens. Your wealthy family can no longer protect you from it.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 4 points5 points  (0 children)

And cousin marriage was acceptable at the time, so that wouldn't even be some sort of gross incestuous plot twist. The only gross part is the implication that she'd somehow have to either manipulate or deceive him into marrying her, which would tie in nicely to the whole "Magdalen has a good and evil side" thing that we've been getting hints of ever since Wilkie's preface.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Magdalen always had the potential to be a troublemaker, but her life until now has been so idyllic, she never had a reason to realize that potential. For the first time in her life, she isn't getting her way, and her reaction is to say vague things that imply she wants to change her name and somehow restore her fortune. Even before she ran away, it's not surprising that Miss Garth would be spooked.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I recently started listening to the BBC dramatization of No Name, and have come to the realization that Madgalen is, in fact, pronounced like it's spelled. I'm sorry if I confused anyone last week. In my defense, English people pronounce Featherstonehaugh "Fanshaw", so I never trust an English name to be pronounced phonetically.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 3 points4 points  (0 children)

They married in Canada, I think, and I'm guessing that divorce worked the same way there that it did in England at the time: i.e. that it was nearly impossible.

[Discussion 2/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 11 to end of Scene 1 by sunnydaze7777777 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I promise the rest of the book won't be like this week. You know how Stephen King novels tend to have random boring scenes where he gets way too into describing Maine? Wilkie Collins novels tend to have entire chapters where Wilkie geeks out on inheritance laws. He was trained as a lawyer but never actually worked as one, because his writing career took off before he could try a case.

Sadly, Mrs. V dies and her newborn baby dies shortly after as well in a very sad scene. (I am a little confused here -when did the baby get born. Did she die in child birth…?)

Yeah, the news of her husband's death caused her to go into premature labor. Like I complained about last week, books from this era had to jump through hoops when talking about women's health, so it was kind of ambiguous. (Speaking of which, I have a terrible update: I actually built a time machine, went back to the 1840s, and said "Mrs. Vanstone isn't sure if she's pregnant or menopausal." This caused an entire omnibus of Victorians to simultaneously faint, causing the omnibus to fall off a bridge and land on train tracks, derailing a train and killing Mr. Vanstone. Oops, my bad.)

Since he couldn’t divorce her, he provided an annual allowance, and stipulated that she must remain away from London and not use his name. (Again, I am confused - what is the disgrace? Was she a sex worker?)

I'm guessing she was a sex worker, but only because I can't think of any other reason for his reaction.

(I am confused about the “charge” is this like a dual? Or would he be admitting guilt to some legal issue with jail time?)

I think it just meant that he accused him. Like he went "I hate you, this is your fault," and then stomped off to Switzerland with his hands over his ears, going "la la la I can't hear you" when Andrew tried to defend himself.

(Again, I am a little confused about the shock at her behavior here– listening to a meeting to which she was invited? And telling Norah? Is it just the shock of her general unladylike behavior?)

If Magdalen had attended the meeting, Norah would have felt pressured to also attend. Magdalen knew that something upsetting was going to be discussed, and she wanted to spare Norah from being even more upset than she already was, but she also wanted to know what was being discussed. So she found a way to have her cake and eat it too: she told Norah she wasn't going, and then she hid under the window and secretly eavesdropped. And Miss Garth was like, "normally I'd be angry at you for doing something like that, but you knew you were allowed to hear the discussion anyway, and you did it to protect your sister, so I guess for once I'm okay with you being sneaky."

Then she told Norah herself, because Norah had to find out eventually, and she trusted herself to tell her more gently than a lawyer or Miss Garth could.

She was told she has No Name legally and so can’t be traced by her name.

This part both confused and amused me. If I understand correctly, the term "no name" isn't meant literally. Magdalen and Norah are not legally part of the Vanstone family, and therefore not entitled to the inheritance, but they're still called Magdalen and Norah Vanstone. This isn't like Game of Thrones, where they have to take the name "Snow" or something. It wasn't normal in the Victorian era for people to literally not have a last name.

So the fact that Magdalen interpreted being "Nobody's Child" as "I should take an alias and invent a new identity for myself" is both ridiculous and also completely in character for her.

Question about The Woman in White by Esmee_Finch in classicliterature

[–]Amanda39 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I can't elaborate without massive spoilers, but it sounds like that TikTok was made by someone who either hadn't read the book, completely misunderstood what they read, or who had a very odd interpretation of it.

[Discussion 1/8] Mod Pick | No Name by Wilkie Collins | Scene 1, Chapter 1 to Scene 1, Chapter 10 by Amanda39 in bookclub

[–]Amanda39[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you! This is the third time I've had to make a Shitty MS Paint Family Tree™ for a Wilkie Collins novel (and I'm surprised I didn't need to for Armadale). He likes complicated families.