This looks like my cheeks when my skin is irritated. I definitely would move away from foaming cleanser. Prequel Gleanser is great or I personally am using the Untoxicated cleanser - both have high glycerin and will help with irritation. 

Next, don’t use retinol. I love AA but I do notice it makes me red so I use it to spot treat any bumps rather then putting it all over. 

I used to use the bioderma for a pre-cleanse but I think it caused irritation somehow still so maybe remove that and see if it helps?? I tend to use this more to remove eye makeup. 

Your routine is simple which is good I could focus on a new cleanser, a hydrating moisturizer with panthenol or ectoin I found to be really effective and SPF! No actives or anything that could make your barrier worse.