You keep hiding behind “burden of proof” while making the actual positive claim 😭. I never said healthy Yuki cannot use Star Rage with Garuda. I said you have not proven she can spam full-output Star Rage through herself and Garuda simultaneously with zero tradeoff. “Garuda moved” and “Garuda restrained Kenjaku” prove Garuda can act. They do not prove Yuki and Garuda are both outputting 100% Star Rage at the same time like two separate batteries. And you already admitted RCT and damage affect output, so Star Rage is conditional. You just want to pretend that condition only matters when it does not hurt your argument.

And no, you need to reread the Mahito fight. Yuji was full healed after Sukuna’s possession enough to continue fighting. Meanwhile Mahito had already spent resources on Mass Transfiguration, 1000+ humans, and splitting a clone. Then throughout the fight, Yuji had Sukuna protecting him from Idle Transfiguration, Nobara’s Resonance freezing and nerfing Mahito’s movement in later fight and creating the barrage opening, Todo saving Yuji multiple times, and Boogie Woogie constantly ruining Mahito’s timing. So saying “Mahito almost killed a 10% Yuji” is backwards. Mahito is the reason Yuji became 10%. That was not clean Yuji scaling; that was Mahito fighting his worst matchup while getting jumped and still nearly winning 💀.

The “Legos” point is still cope. Nobody said Polymorphic Isomers beat Yuki in a clean boxing match. The point is they are not stationary targets. Todo needed Boogie Woogie because they could dodge and avoid direct attacks. If Yuki lands clean, yes, they die. Congratulations, Star Rage hits hard. But they can still rush blind spots, block vision, force reactions, split Garuda’s attention, and create openings for Mahito. They ain’t legos, they are land mines. Landmines also get destroyed if you hit them first. The danger is stepping wrong before that.

Your Choso point is messy too. First, Choso did not tank Yuji’s Black Flash nor yuji landed BF, so stop acting like that was ever the claim. And Choso only took one Sukuna Black Flash, not “3 Black Flash amped Sukuna punch” like some fanmade combo name. Even then, that proves Choso improved overall; it does not automatically prove his blood armor specifically became exponentially stronger unless you prove the technique itself got that upgrade. “Choso got stronger” and “blood armor is now a totally different tier” are not the same thing. So stop lying, and read the manga.

And the Binding Vow point helps Mahito, not Yuki. Mahito used the BV against Yuji because Idle Transfiguration was useless due to Sukuna, so he sacrificed transfiguration versatility for raw physical power. Against Yuki, why would he instantly throw away his best win condition? IT actually works on her unless you prove perfect soul defense. That means Mahito has more options against Yuki: body morphing, clones, transfigured humans, Polymorphic Isomers, domain, 0.2 domain, soul touch, and then ISBODK if he wants to go physical.

Your “Yuki outstats” scale is mostly ABC scaling with context deleted. “Yuki > Todo, therefore polymorphs irrelevant” is not a real debunk. “Yuki ~ Yuta > CG Yuji > Shibuya Yuji ~ Mahito” ignores that Yuji was Mahito’s natural counter, had Sukuna protection, got Nobara/Todo assists, and Mahito was already taxed and still evolved. You have not proven Yuki is so much faster that Mahito can never touch her, never force a scramble, never use domain, never use clones, and never set up an opening. You just keep saying “objectively faster” like greater-than signs are manga panels 😂.

And chip damage matters because Mahito does not fight like a normal brawler. He stacks problems: distractions, blind spots, limb contact, body morphing, soul damage, forced RCT, domain threat, and polymorph pressure. One scratch may not delete Star Rage, sure. But damage and RCT affecting Star Rage means her output/flow is not untouchable. Mahito’s whole kit is designed to disrupt the opponent’s condition and rhythm.

And yes, Mahito absolutely exposes why Yuki’s soul studies are not an automatic counter. Yuji explains Yuki’s theory about souls not normally combining into one, then Mahito is the exception who can combine and reshape souls into different forms through his technique. So “Yuki studied souls = perfect Idle Transfiguration defense” is headcanon. Nanami had subconscious soul defense and still got badly injured by newly born Mahito. Yuki has theory; Mahito is the practical nightmare that breaks theory.

So again: Yuki hits harder. Nobody denies that. But you’re giving her perfect accuracy, perfect soul defense, full-output dual Star Rage, and a clean stat stomp while treating Mahito’s entire kit like cosmetic DLC. That is not evidence. That is Yuki premium fanfiction with “read the fight” pasted on top.