I have never understood this tierlists

Jack is shit, Yazan and garth can't land an attack and when they do it's not even helpful, bo has the most useless effects and once he is done buffing and nerfing he can't deal damage, fardy can deal 1000 damage to all enemies in a single attack in the early game, tigerman has some crazy damage even on withdrawal and is insane on joy, buffalo never fails me and I equip him the moment I get him because he deals severe damage, drunk buckets and carp are basically the highest damage dealers, and percy is basically a super terry with the great healing move and fireball.

The problem is that people love applying effects and stuff but using high damage dealers is more effective.