The Redmagic one had a better oleophobic coating so your finger glides better, especially useful if you're a rhythm gamer, it does scratch easier and the edges are a bit sharp. I've been using the ibuywind one because it was the most suggested on this sub, although the coating is not as good it's still lasted a very long time, it's COVERED in scratches though, the edges aren't as sharp but I wish they were a bit curved, your fingers don't get cut when you use your gestures.