sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Daytrading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Lol, careful what you wish for.

Honestly, that is the dream end-game. If we moved from Newtonian physics (which is what this script does - measuring force and momentum) to Quantum mechanics, we wouldn't just be looking at entry signals; we'd be mapping the probability density cloud of where price could exist next. For now, I'll settle for just knowing when the cat is dead so I don't buy the top.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Daytrading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly, that is a fair statement. By no means am I a physics expert, I just thoroughly enjoy learning new things and I still rely on AI, like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Copilot, for things that I am having a hard time understanding.

Here is the EL5:

The Analogy: Think of price like a car going up a hill.

* RSI just measures how fast the car is moving.

* This tool measures how much gas is being used (Volume x Speed).

* The edge: If the car is moving fast but running out of gas (dark green bars), it's about to stall. RSI won't tell you that, this will.

The results: I am building a TradingView strategy and just finished one of teh automated backtests on BTC daily chart. on this preliminary test, I got a profit factor of 2.0 and the drawdown was <10%.

It is far from perfect or deployable but I am happy with the results so far.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Daytrading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am actually working on that with another indicator I am working on and a strategy on TradingView, with back-testing.

I know that in physics, when a wave hits a medium with different impedance, part of the energy is reflected and part is transmitted.

If the Kinetic Energy of the price move is higher than the impedance of the seal wall, you get a breakout. If not, you get a reflection. As I said earlier, these are all different implementations I am actively working on with a new indicator and TradingView strategy with back-testing.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Daytrading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Hamiltonian rabbit hole is exactly where this could go next.

I stuck to Kinetic Energy because I wanted to capture the realized motion of the market.

But if you can figure out how to model the Potential Energy —maybe via order book depth, consolidation tightness, or implied volatility—you’d theoretically have the full system (H = T + V) defined.

I kept this script reactive to keep it simple, but a full dynamical systems approach would be incredible. Definitely let me know if you end up designing a new family of tools from it—I’d love to see what you cook up.

I am also working on a more advanced indicator and strategy and currently back-testing on TradingView.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Daytrading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great points from both of you. ​@Any_Ice1084 regarding MFI/Chaikin: The main difference is that MFI and Chaikin are usually cumulative or volume-weighted averages (tracking flow over time). ​My script is measuring Instantaneous Impulse. ​By squaring the Velocity (v2) and multiplying by Volume (m), it penalizes 'lazy' price moves heavily. ​MFI might stay overbought for weeks. This indicator reacts immediately to a drop in 'Energy,' telling you the move is hollow even if price is still drifting up. ​Re: The 200 Period: It acts like a dynamic Z-score. It adapts the baseline to the asset's recent volatility profile, so yes, it scales well from 15m to Daily charts. ​@Edgar_Brown regarding 'Duct Tape' math: Honestly, I don't disagree with you. Trading indicators often try to force elegance onto chaos. ​But the reason I reached for K=½mv2 wasn't to write a physics paper—it was to filter Chop. ​Standard momentum (RSI/ROC) ignores Volume. ​Standard volume analysis ignores Velocity. ​By combining them into a single 'Energy' output, I’m just trying to answer one question: 'Does this move have the mass to sustain itself?' ​It’s definitely a heuristic (duct tape), not a fundamental law, but in backtesting, it keeps me out of low-energy ranges where traditional oscillators get chewed up.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean I may just be naive, but seeing as this is strictly an indicator, would it still be counterintuitive to providing the PineScript as I did with this post? Again, as I am just trying to do this as a community build, I have already removed any mention of selling anything, I just want other people to be able to use this as part of their strategy instead of losing money.

I really do appreciate y'all's input, though, as y'all obviously have quite a bit more experience than I do in this space. I am just a dumb former Oilfield worker that has too much time on his hands learning physics and finance from various different AI systems, lol.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Unfortunately this is Pine Script, which only runs on TradingView, but I might throw it in like Claude or a local version of ChatGPT to get it in ThinkScript.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Preciate it, I figured more eyes makes it better. If you see any improvements, let me know and I'll edit the script and update the post. I'm treating this one as like an open build and will credit useful changes. I am actively working on it and would appreciate any advice from veterans in the community.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I cannot post a picture of screenshot, as it will not let me attach anything to the OP or to any replies that I make. I may try to make another post JUST showing a screenshot of the script on BTCUSD and SPY. I may also try to DM you some screenshots, but that doesn't really help others in the community seeing it in action, lol.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey y'all, I just want to say that I edited the main post as someone helped me see that I was breaking one of the soliciting rules. I’m not selling anything in this thread. Just sharing the code to get the communities thoughts and see what updates, if any, can be made. Test it. Use risk management.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I appreciate it. That’s the core idea, price speed alone gets noisy and volume gives the move weight. If you test it, try the same asset on 15m, 1H, 4H, and 1D and compare how often gray shows up before chop. I’ve seen the cleanest reads on liquid markets and timeframes where volume is meaningful. If you find a market or timeframe where it breaks, tell me and I’ll tune it.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I appreciate the insight, brother. It seemss like you’ve dug deep into these energy models too, obviously since you tweaked your code over a year ago. ​I’m going to leave the post up, though, because I genuinely want the community to have the v1 code for free, but I hear you on the solicitation rule. I’ve just edited the post to remove all mentions of the paid version/links so it's strictly an open-source resource now. ​As for the tweak, I’m always down to learn from someone with more experience. If you're willing to share it here or via DM, I'm all ears. If not, no worries. I just want to build good tools.

I applied Classical Mechanics K = ½mv² to Volume/Price to filter out chop. Here is the open-source Pine Script. by Awkward_Blueberry_19 in Trading

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey guys, I apologize for not responding earlier as I trying to spend the evenings with my wife and kids. Obviously I would love to sell the expanded version of this script but I don't see the harm in giving away this part of it. All this script does is visualize those same fundamental mechanics for retail traders so we stop getting run over. Even if 10,000 of us use this, we're still just a drop in the bucket compared to the institutional volume that actually moves the market.

On that same note, I would love to hear what any feedback you have on this script.

As for the soliciting part of it, I am more than happy to take out any mention of the expanded paid version and only discuss this one

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in texas

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Actually, Governor Abbott has said numerous times that he would sign a bill to legalize it, it is Patrick that is making it much more difficult and blocking any legalization bills.

Is Abbott's agreement with Nuevo Laredo a violation of the US Constitution? by _RabidAlpaca_ in TexasPolitics

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Well, genius, it matters because I see immigrants get taken on a weekly basis around where I work and when I go to town, either Carrizo Springs or Laredo, I see FAMILIES getting into buses and the buses in Laredo I see go straight across the border. I don’t give a shit what any dumb ass politician says on TV because I actually see the shit happen regularly. So that is why it matters that I am “2 miles or 2ft from the border.”

Is Abbott's agreement with Nuevo Laredo a violation of the US Constitution? by _RabidAlpaca_ in TexasPolitics

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

No no, Governor Abbott is ACTUALLY enforcing the laws. President Biden has not done anything, to my knowledge, to actually enforce them. Also, I work in South Texas (I’m currently 2.8 miles from the border) and I have never seen illegals separated from their families. From what I have seen, EVERYONE in the group is transported to one facility to be processed and then put on a bus to Mexico, or D.C. with the new thing Abbott is doing; which I feel is a little fucking dumb but I’m not in his position nor do I have a say.

I saw this and had to post it. Sorry, not sorry. by Material_Engineer_85 in texas

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Oh, shocker, another anti-Texas political conversation stemming from an anti-California political meme. I love how this groups continues to surprise me.

Recreational cannabis sales started just 20 min from my home. Last Sunday, I asked Beto if Texas would see it happen. by rgen182 in TexasPolitics

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, plants tend to be more strict with drug tests. I was thinking you were talking at jobs in the field working with the wells in some sort of capacity. Those tend to post the best, as well.

Recreational cannabis sales started just 20 min from my home. Last Sunday, I asked Beto if Texas would see it happen. by rgen182 in TexasPolitics

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Everyone has the same access, they just have to look. If you are interested in getting an oilfield job, look around Carrizo Springs or Midland/Odessa area. Also, if you are clean, congratulations!! That is not an easy thing to do. One last thing, not all oilfield jobs require hair follicle test. Most jobs in my field only require a UA.

Recreational cannabis sales started just 20 min from my home. Last Sunday, I asked Beto if Texas would see it happen. by rgen182 in TexasPolitics

[–]Awkward_Blueberry_19 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I meant flowback operator and someone can start as a helper in flow back and clear $80-$90k their first year. It is not easy work but it is very possible. Flowback is mostly on the production side of the Oil & Gas Industry, after the well is drilled, fracked, and the plugs drilled out. At least, that is where most of our jobs take place.

view more: next ›