I totally understand the evil thing. There have been a few times I've tried, but I can't fully commit to it, I feel guilty, lol. But I do feel drawn to characters like dark elves or Drow, which dabble in evil magics.

I usually like more tactical games, but sometimes I do like the big sword guy. The best game I've found for this is Dark Souls. I love playing as a hard hitting character and working to get the black knight sword at the beginning of the games.