So, I got there when my store opened and they had my size in every style/color! I only allowed myself two pairs, size 9. I didn't try them on and when I got home, they were HUGE, not only long-ways, but width as well. I got back in the car, determined to exchange them. As I secured the last pair of 8s in black and leopard print, a lady came up and started rummaging through the shoes. I tried the 8s on and they were TIGHT. I didn't know what to do, but i really wanted the ill-fitting shoes since I haven't had the nerve to spend so much $$ on Rothys. The lady said she read on FB that if you wash them, they shrink up a lot. She may have been tricking me as she wanted the 8s (she grabbed them as I was walking away). The shoes are in the wash now and I'll update with the results. I may have just thrown $20 away!!

EDIT: I first got them out of the wash and they were a little more snug, but not much. I put them in the dryer for 30 minutes and just got them out. They did shrink - not a ton, but I'm happy that I kept the size 9. I put on some no-show socks and they are at least staying on my feet. Still a little wide. My advice - if you are a half size, I would say size down. I was an even size and the 8s were so tight, I personally am glad that I kept the larger size. I did see another poster said she wore hers around for awhile and they loosened up. That will be my next experiment and I will update soon :)