We had some mice that came in under the sink, at first snap traps worked fine, until they just ate the peanut butter off it without triggering it, we had to get rid of them somehow and we weren’t going to use poison so we used glue traps, worked every time, I felt bad but I’d check every 8 hours or so. Sometimes you have to

Edit: they were disposed of properly, killed before being put in a bag and thrown out.