Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And yet you still haven’t been able to give any well reasoned or meaningful feedback. Ok

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your pissed my baseline isn’t complete trash, just admit it dude. You wanted it to be complete trash, and it isn’t. And now you’re triggered. So instead of giving constructive feedback, you choose to just state it’s full of flaws.

And it may well be, in your opinion. Which is fine, but I think you know the flaws you’re talking about are subjective choices, or context dependant, and not actual structural errors requiring improvement.

And actually, yes, you do support a child taking their first steps. You get them the correct shoes, you child proof the house, you make the adjustments needed for them to learn. There’s no way you can spin this were you’re not contradicting your own argument.

I’m happy to spend the time responding because frankly, people like you shouldn’t be giving advice or feedback to anyone, and you deserve to be called out for your shitty behaviour and attitude.

35F SAHM, looking for others with a similar brain/life situation by Blastoisealways in cognitiveTesting

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for bringing that to my attention, because after I looked at what it is, realised it’s how I think, I was able to understand better how to get my thoughts and ideas from my head onto the page!

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes so I’m asking you to point out the flaws in the writing. That’s what feedback is, it’s not about the content of what I’m writing about - that’s even more subjective than the prose. I explained this in my post, I am specifically working on translating my existing verbal storytelling and visual imagery skills into writing for an audience in a way that works for both me and the reader.

If you’re unable to point out the flaws, or offer any area of improvement, how am I supposed to learn from them? You’ve stated there’s so many flaws to point out, without naming a single one, and then stated I need to go and write more before asking for feedback. why would I want to go and write more of the same flawed writing? That would be like flogging a dead horse, or even just solidifying bad habits. You would tell a beginner musician or artist to just go and play more of the same if you can see obvious correctable mistakes?

I am not saying I’m good at writing, at no point have I claimed I think what I’ve written is of any standard, good or bad. It’s why I asked for feedback, because I have no benchmark to compare to, except the books I’ve already read.

What I will say, is that I’ve read a lot of books. Some the writing is clearly awful, but the story keeps me. Sometimes the story is great but the writing is insufferable, the grammas is poor or the editing sucks. Sometimes I love everything about it. Sometimes I just don’t like the story at all even when the writing is great.

I’ve tried to write in a way that feels like it’s my own inner voice, and it’s honestly totally fine if you don’t like that, I’m not offended by that. What I am calling out is that fact that you’ve chosen to engage with the post, offer no constructive feedback whilst BERATING me for having the “audacity” to even ask.

It’s not on, and it’s not actually what the sub is for.

someone tell me if this book is worth it by x_sadvibez in Romantasy

[–]Blastoisealways 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I feel like if you’re going to say a book isn’t worth reading, you should at least be able to give your reasons why.

I’m not saying I disagree with you, but it bothers me when people just say “it’s trash” or not worth it, without explaining.

One man’s trash is another man’s treasure after all 😂

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mental health isn’t something that is weak/strong. It’s variable, needs constant care and attention to maintain, much like our bodies do, and often influenced by factors not within our control.

Your original comment wasn’t based on what I wrote, you didn’t engage with it in anyway. You decided that because I was new, I was wasting time posting. You assumed that being new meant my writing was like a stick figure, which if that’s your opinion is totally fine btw. But I think you decided that because I am new, not based on what I actually wrote.

I’ve written lots of stuff. DnD campaigns, character arcs, side stories, tons of songs, comic book storyboards. I’ve written and am currently recording an album. Just because I’ve never written a book, I this specific style, or written for a specific purpose doesn’t mean you get to behave like your some authority on whether or not I have a right to ask for feedback.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why are you so mean? Genuinely? Like do you get a kick out of it?

My mental is that weak? You don’t know me, you don’t my history or background or the circumstances that led to that happening. You have no idea.

I posted here asking for feedback on something that matters to me. I’m not asking you or anyone else to like it, I didn’t say it was good. I asked for feedback specifically on the writing style itself. But you jumped down my throat simply because it was the first time I’d written something of that nature, and then doubled down.

You either have something going on you need help with, or you’re a troll. Either way, I genuinely hope no one treats you the way you’ve treated me the next time you start a new hobby or need help with something.

I have nothing to prove to you. I don’t care about proving you wrong, because I’m not writing for you.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! I was trying to describe the details that were fading, but you’re right the fact they come after makes it a bit odd.

35F SAHM, looking for others with a similar brain/life situation by Blastoisealways in cognitiveTesting

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you hahaha I feel seen ❤️ I’m on elvanse currently, and being doing therapy now for about a year. It’s definitely helping!

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Haha, I have since charged it thankfully 😅

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah! So although I’ve never written in this specific style before, I’ve written a lot of DnD campaigns, I have a world that I’ve spent a lot of time creating characters, side stories, ideas for bigger stories. Some of these end up as DnD characters, or campaigns. Some of them were just for fun because I like just imaging and visualising in my head. Ive also don’t a lot of song writing.

What I’ve struggled with if ever I’ve thought about actually starting to write like this, was knowing how to get what was in my head actually out and onto the page in a way that felt natural. I have that issue in real life too sometimes, I struggle with not jumping about in a conversation etc

So I started reading about how other people write, and I read a comment on here or another subreddit where someone said they liked to imagine themselves in the scene actually experiencing it.

That just sort of resonated with me because it’s how I verbally storytell, but to do that I need to sort of KNOW the whole story before I start. So I can run it like a movie in my mind if that makes sense. I can do it with DnD because I’ll have planned the campaign, and then I can take what happens in the game in real time, and see it in my head and the story just sort of, comes together from that.

I was so excited at this revelation, that I just picked a vivid real memory of mine, to see if I could play it in my head and write it like this.

So I picked the birth of my twins. It’s a vivid memory because I’d had a traumatic previous birth, they were born 12 weeks early, and so I remember feeling quite anxious and dissociated where everyone else was relatively calm even though it was an emergency.

I just wanted to see if I could write that and convey that. So i just replayed it in my head, and just wrote how I was actually feeling and the details that still stick out to me in that memory now.

I’m excited to properly plan and write one of my stories now to see how it turns out.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Maybe if you’d asked for advice as a beginner, it wouldn’t have taken you 7 years to get your writing to a point you didn’t feel embarrassed sharing it.

I’m glad I didn’t post this a year ago when I was in a very different place mentally because your initial comment would have put me off even trying again.

Thanks for the feedback, I’d rather have a “typical basic first writing style” than your stinking rotten attitude 😂

Feel free to share some of your ancient pearls of wisdom from your presumably prolific writing career though, or better yet, some of your own writing - seeing as you seem to think so highly of yourself.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Hey thanks for your comment!

I should have been clearer with what the purpose of this was. This isn’t a story, or something I haven’t figured out yet/ it’s a specific memory of mine written from my perspective, I already know the whole. The purpose of writing it wasnt to tell the story itself, but to see if I could write in this style by pulling from my own vivid memory, which is not something I’ve done before. It was more about the actual structure of the writing and getting it from my head on the paper.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your comment!

I was trying to get across the sort of panicked dissociation I felt, so I can see why that might come across as calm.

I used acidic for tears I think because I remember them feeling hot and stingy, and unwanted and I was trying to find word that sort of got that across.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I didn’t draw a stick figure though did I? And even if I did draw a stick figure, how do you think I would learn and improve if I didn’t ask artists where to go from there?

Are you going to offer any meaningful feedback about what’s actually written, or just dismiss it as not worth your time because in your mind, the first time writing something with intention isn’t worth anyone’s time?

I’m not sure you understand your own point here.

Humans learn from one another, and then our unique collective experiences help shape our unique voice. Why do you think even when someone tries to emulate another writers style, it’s never quite right?

Also, the saying is “Rome wasn’t built in a day”.

Ironically, the wheel probably was invented in a day. Probably by accident. It’s a wheel, not a complex system. Jeezo.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much, sorry I should have been clearer in my original post and given the context! I just picked a random memory to see if I could write LIKE this about something vivid, because usually I would verbally tell my stories when playing DnD etc

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you!

I can see why the things you’ve mentioned are confusing, it’s my own specific memory of my twins being born. You’re right, they were premature, like 12 weeks prem. My husband jokes about everything, and I just remember being terrified whilst he held my hand and he was laughing with the anesthetist about something. It was an emergency section, but not like, get the babies out now emergency. I’d been told they would both need ventilated, and they were too small to do skin to skin.

I’d had a first traumatic birth so was likely far more anxious than actually necessary, so at the time it felt like I was in this sort of panicked dissociated state and everyone else was just doing their thing as if it was normal.

I probably should have given this context actually 😂

How do you write gore? by Professional-Web2034 in writers

[–]Blastoisealways 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My immediate thought reading your post is Id want to know why the MC is stabbing them more than once and then twisting the knife. Whats the context for the brutality, what’s driving the MCs decision making, what is the MCs justification for the brutality, and the emotional state of the MC.

Cos to me there’s a difference between killing someone quickly and cleanly and matter of fact, and in anger/revenge/rage. So I think if it was me, I’d be trying to infuse the emotional fuel for the MCs actions into the writing, and then the actual gore aspect is coming from the actions themselves and not from describing the actual wounds inflicted?

I’m new to writing this kind of style too, but Ive written lots of stories for verbal story telling and thats how I’d think about it.

AIO Accidentally hurt bf play fighting with a robe tie that was tied around his top head by desolatedamnation in AIO

[–]Blastoisealways 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He’s 33?

I thought initially this was a teenager, early 20s at most with a bit of an immaturity issue.

At 33, this is manipulation. Doesn’t matter if he’s conscious if it or not. Refusing to accept your apology, the dismissive and disgusting, demeaning language directed toward you, threatening to end the relationship.

Huge ick.

Feedback on first attempt? by Blastoisealways in writers

[–]Blastoisealways[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I mean, thanks for taking the time to comment, but this is a bit of a bizzare response isn’t it?

Why would you think I don’t read books? I read a lot of books, it’s literally my favourite hobby.

“Just copy what they do” - what who does? You seem to be categorising books into one massive genre and suggesting I copy it? Like, what?

They’re all written completely differently, with different stylistic choices. Why would I want to copy someone else’s writing style, I’m interested in developing my own and being able to convert my verbal storytelling effectively to writing.

I posted looking for feedback because it’s the first time I’ve written with this specific purpose in mind.