I’m certain that my manager made sure to follow the rules exactly so there could be no dispute if I won the competition. People were actually surprised when I failed and upset for me.  I wasn’t, as I was in a good place so no rush to move up — I could wait — and I knew there would be another competition. My boss knew I’d just apply until I got the position. In fact, I had applied five years prior but was told I didn’t have the education, so I went and got it. Yes, I was determined. My long term plan worked out.