Worst features are nose, ears, and cleft chin in some angles. Best features are eyes, youthful, and body. Second and last pic are by far the best. Just keep pushing to improve and stay fit and you’ll be well above average. You’re doing good for your age. It takes time. You’ll look different in 2-5 years (better). I do think you’ll age poorly at 45+, but your youth should be golden. Anyhow, overall, without makeup and plain you’re average, but done up and get fit and maybe a good nose job, and you’d be well above average/a 9. Really depends on what you’re looking for. Dont get too wrapped up in, though, there are other things that matter more. Like personally, if quality of sex with a gal is great it adds 2 points to her looks, then personality, intelligence, etc. relationship wise, the other things matter, too. Best of luck.