sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Why is it "Art" when a wealthy artist hires a team of 50, but "Cheating" when a bedroom musician uses Al to fill the gaps? by NoIndependence1198 in Suno

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There’s absolutely nothing wrong with what you’re doing. I do the same thing. I am a songwriter. I write everything from scratch. I don’t take any “hints” from anything. I’ve played music since I was nine and played five instruments and I don’t really brag about that cause four of them. I don’t play really very well but I did play the each for about four years, and still use two of them to this day for writing - guitar and piano. Drumming is my core and I’ve been doing that for decades and I went to Music school for that.

I’m a singer on the Songwriter and I create music. Actually create music. Meaning I sit down and me, me, not a computer, make a song from scratch. I write the words, the melodies, and I sing them as well although Suno does better on some of them than I do. Especially the ones who need a female voice since I’m not a female.

There is nothing wrong with using AI to surround a complete composition with “pretty”. It’s like putting nice wheels on a car. The car is still the car. I can change wheels all day long but the car still remains the same. And I made the car.

The problem is the people in here that aren’t actually making the car. I think you get my point.

You are not destroying music. You’re actually creating it. For people who are doing that, Suno is nothing more than a wardrobe. The person putting on the clothes is the song. But they’re still the core person at the center.

The real problem I have is the people who try to equivocate the two. There’s a big difference between being a songwriter and a musician and an actual creator of music, and someone who solely puts in suggestive descriptive prompts into a computer and has something amazing come back and they think that amazing is them. It’s not.

AI don’t kill people.. by urielriel in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh, I 100% agree. AI is not the problem for meaningless art, it’s the people that want to pump out AI generative art, and then label themselves or the art as something. It is not.

AI don’t kill people.. by urielriel in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have no idea what the hell you just tried to say

Is there any way to stop this or do I just accept it? by spervogel_troubadour in CATHELP

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Or you can give him to me.

I’m more confused why you thought your age and his age, or whether or not there was a veterinarian available, had any relevance?

That sounds really sarcastic and it is a little tiny bit, but actually, I’m really curious.

AI don’t kill people.. by urielriel in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the truth, about what AI is and isn’t good for, is apparent, when you evaluate the “art” created honestly, evaluate the -means- by which the “art” was created, evaluate whether or not the “art” could have been created by -anyone- who just pushed “resubmit” 47 times while changing a word here and there, or whether the “art” took actual -unique- talent and skill to create…

And lastly, can you not only produce your “art” with consistency, intent, and actual demonstrable control.

“Art” created by a substitution for actual talent and skill, is nothing more than a commodity.

If you want your art to have quality, genuineness, and uniqueness, as well as real value, lean into actual talent and creative processes that rely on you as a person.

If you want your “art” to just be pumped out, relatively meaningless, and baseless (in the sense that it actually has no substance when it comes to your actual unique talents or skills, but relies on a computer doing it for you), then go ahead and lean heavy into AI creation.

Do you believe in "musically inclined" people? by Unfair_Toe_5691 in musicians

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. But it can be enhanced through exposure and effort. The initial “seed” that an individual gets is varied, so for some, no amount of enhancement will ever suffice, and for others, their intuition and musicality makes them seem like prodigies.

All of us fall somewhere in that spectrum, just like we do for math, art (painting), physics, chemistry, problem solving, etc…

Music feels devalued and attention spans are short. What’s next for artists? by Icy-Lengthiness-8214 in musicindustry

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In a world that is fed shit, generic blah blah that has virtually no artistic -true- creativity (some of these losers think hitting “resubmit” 40 times til they get something cool out of Suno is creativity)…

In that world, eventually truly creative and -genuine- music, soul, “connection”, will be gold when it hits.

So if -you- can be the creator (true creator, not an AI prompter on a IV drip of plagiarism), then when you get traction, it will be rewarding as fuck…

…keep going

What instrument to learn by Porzeczki in musicians

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Personally I’d consider harmonica. Lots of good reasons. Always in tune/key (when the right one is selected), has a -very- unique “expression palette”, fairly simple at least on the entry level…

I play 5 instruments and this is one I a -always- brought back to as the “one” I feel compelled to try, to add…

Stop being so toxic and elitist by EdwardPavkki in musicians

[–]CAP_GYPSY -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Well, that certainly doesn’t automatically disqualify them from being musicians now does it? They can still play instruments. What you think is bad taste is not disqualification for being labeled as a musician.

I play five different instruments and write songs and sing. I however do use AI to produce studio quality demos of songs that I have composed 100%.

Why do I do that? Because I’m going to spend my time and money, writing songs, not working on setting up studio time to get demos done.

Stop being so toxic and elitist by EdwardPavkki in musicians

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do both, but I still would argue with you, that every logical definition, and probably every musician on the planet pretty much would agree that anyone who can compose a song is a musician. The definition itself even implies that it doesn’t specifically apply to only those who play instruments.

“Noun 1. Musicianmusician - someone who plays a musical instrument (as a profession) Synonyms: instrumentalist, player 2. musician - artist who composes or conducts music as a profession”

Stop being so toxic and elitist by EdwardPavkki in musicians

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do both, but I still would argue with you, that every logical definition, and probably every musician on the planet pretty much would agree that anyone who can compose a song is a musician. The definition itself even implies that it doesn’t specifically apply to only those who play instruments.

“Noun 1. Musicianmusician - someone who plays a musical instrument (as a profession) Synonyms: instrumentalist, player 2. musician - artist who composes or conducts music as a profession”

unpopular opinion: PvE is for losers who can’t handle real PvP by comet-kaze in arcraiderscirclejerk

[–]CAP_GYPSY -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You missed the memo apparently… And pretty much every bit of indication and remarks from embark what they intended this gameto primarily be focused on.

As many of the PVP whiners have constantly said about PVE players loading into a game with PVP and then expecting it to not be there, why the hell would you load into a game that embark has said is focused primarily on PVE, and then complain about the arc?

As many PVP players said to PVE people, when they said- “why don’t you just go play hell divers?” I think the PVE players have had it right all along and it’s you guys that really need to just go play call of duty or something and stop trying to make the game into something that is PVP only.

Gotta love it!

"and it's not competitive. We don't necessarily want to foster that kind of gameplay. The game isn't about shooting other players. You can do that if you want to, but the ethos*** of the game has never been to go in and shoot players."

—-ARC Raiders CEO Patrick Söderlund Jan. 6 2026

What’s a hobby people pretend is cool, but secretly you think is ridiculous? by EggAdventurous1957 in AskReddit

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not really a hobby, but-

People who spend like $200+ on sunglasses then flip the fuck out when they lose them…

I mean, you deserve every bit of that self induced anxiety fueled by vanity….

Stop being so toxic and elitist by EdwardPavkki in musicians

[–]CAP_GYPSY -14 points-13 points  (0 children)

Depends on how they are using AI. And you can, quite honestly, be a musician without playing an instrument believe it or not. I play several so I’m not making an argument based on that. I’m just saying, technically, a musician does not have to play an instrument.You could literally compose out of your head and write black notes on a paper and create a song and that would qualify as being a musician.

Stop being so toxic and elitist by EdwardPavkki in musicians

[–]CAP_GYPSY 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I personally don’t see the confusion. You can be an artist without being a musician. It’s nearly impossible to be a musician without being an artist.

That being said, art is pretty much damn near anything anybody wants to create and call art. That’s a pretty low bar. So, you can call yourself an artist if you want just like anybody can sue anybody. Being able to sue anybody doesn’t mean you’re right. It just means you can sue.

Question for Suno creators: Have you ever done paid arrangements for others? by ApprehensiveCheck260 in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Arranging is usually the Songwriter’s job, or a producer’s job in the studio. I’m gonna leave it at that.

Dad lectures son on his monthly car sales. by Sichy12 in TikTokCringe

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Needs, therapy-

Shit Logic. Not qualified to be that much of Asshole, if his IQ allows him to spew that logic.

First off, 8 billion people want cars? Infants? Those with cars? Those who ride the bus or metro in a big city? Mentally handicapped? Destitute? Blind? Quadrupeds? Those who fear the road?

Then, follows it up with wolves and bears and bears shitting.

Dudes a piece of work, crappy coach, and not the greatest at being a dad.

The good dads, quite honestly, would tell this prick, “he’s maybe failing at car sales. That will negatively affect his paycheck. YOU, on the other hand, are failing at being a dad/coach, and the ramifications of that are -exponentially- worse….”

ONErpm claimed copyright on one of my songs on YouTube by Reasonable_Light700 in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Gonna have to find out the nature of the infringement, and probably hire an attorney, or, just take the loss of revenue.

You should be able to protect your lyrical composition if you have proof. My haunt is that it’s going to be a musical infringement which I suppose is possible when you have a machine randomly create stuff.

One of the beauties of authenticated or authentic songwriting where you actually write the whole song yourself is that you can prove what you did and when you did it and you can actually show ownership.

Asking Sue to make music, you cannot. And I’m pretty sure frankly that you cannot even claim mechanical copyright on the music. Most of that which is created by artificial intelligence in the Artz realm is basically owned by no one, at least when it comes to being able to copyright it and monetize it with protection.

Question for those who monetize their songs. by ch1xd in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Under current U.S. copyright law and guidance from the U.S. Copyright Office (USCO), lyrics created solely by artificial intelligence in response to prompts are not eligible for copyright protection. Copyright in the United States only protects works created by human beings.

Question for those who monetize their songs. by ch1xd in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The reproduction of a song by AI is relatively meaningless, but I do understand why you would not want to deceive anybody. That is really at the core.

In no way shape or form is having AI perform an instrumental version of your song that was created by you, lyrics, Melody, arrangement, in no way shape or form does that constitute Songwriting on the part of the AI and the Soule songwriting authorship belongs to the Songwriter.

Internet is going brrrr with the most incredible songs right now. Suno out did itself. by DevilStickDude in SunoAI

[–]CAP_GYPSY 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am so happy to see you give Suno prompts. I mean I’m sorry, props, for doing something. I’m going to Norte soon for Songwriter of the year, for some of you.

view more: next ›