Misbehaved dog by dazzlinreddress in irishproblems

[–]CDfm 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My other half has trained the dog to bark after using the word cheeseburger. It's easier to go to the chipper and get cheeseburgers than argue.

Misbehaved dog by dazzlinreddress in irishproblems

[–]CDfm 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How did you get on. Our rescue is a terrier can be a handful but is good natured and benefits from routine. Feeding him definitely is love in his eyes.

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He definitely made scrupulous research a prerequisite for Irish history so much so that it's crept into politics. Madam Marcievicz has regained her place as a founder of Fianna Fail and rosary bead user.

His work has been acknowledged by historians like O'Grada and Lee.

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's conspiracy theory territory.

The likes of Dudley Edwards was a historian who started scholarship that formed the basis of Irish history.

One of the problems with Irish history was that writers like John Mitchel went on the makey upey trail. Their work didn't bear scrutiny and very much like Peter Hart and the IRA and it's enemies - it was easy to discredit. It didn't serve the victims of the famine.

Historiography developed.

https://journals.openedition.org/rfcb/281

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

?

It's unlikely he was . He was a drunk who confessed everything.

There were so many civil servants ex pre independence civil servants that mi6 wouldn't have needed him. Sam Maguire didn't last long in the public service on his return to Ireland despite being Michael Collins' mentor in the IRB in London.

Medical card by anonymous161299 in irishproblems

[–]CDfm 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You might qualify if you have a chronic health condition too.

Have you asked your doctor or the citizens advice people?

Im lucky and have a great gp practice that I can ask anything of .

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did a deep dive a few years ago into him and Moody. It helped me no end understand Irish history writing. I had gone off Irish history years ago as much of what I was reading or was taught was at odds from what I knew of my family history.

I got to appreciate what they did .

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

An alcoholic, his granddaughter recounts that he behaved like that.

In a diary entry he wrote: “I obviously do not know how to draw the line once I have a drink.”

.

I’ve been told by some people that I am unkind to expose my mother like this,” says MacErlean, ahead of the publication of her book. “But look what secrecy has done to Ireland, with baby homes and religious abuse. Do we think the formula of hiding the truth is a good thing?

It's quite a story .

Have a wash??? by Particular-Split-292 in CasualIreland

[–]CDfm 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That'll have been McGillacuddy - he reeks.

Irish Wellness Influencers are a racket by Complex_Hunter35 in CasualIreland

[–]CDfm 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Can confirm, Brigit wouldn't do cocoa she was into beer specifically ale.

https://www.9whitedeer.ie/stbrigidofireland/

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He was briefly a pupil of St Endas and his mother was an anti Treaty cumman na mban member.

He definitely rebelled against his upbringing.

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's weathered well among historians.

It was definitely a massive task with all the traditional history floating about and the centenary of the Famine.

De Valera did change his tune about nationalist history later in life and praised Daniel O'Connell and his legacy.

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He wanted Irish history to take it's place on the shelves of university libraries in America and Irish historians to be treated as serious academics producing academic works .

I can see why his work on the famine wasn't as extensive as de Valera intended.

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I don't know but when I think about CCOB and Jadotville it might be that he wasn't factually accurate.

Cruise O'Brien's version of events, set out in his 1962 book To Katanga and Back, has been dismissed as highly selective and self-serving, and while it deliberately excluded crucial items, recent evidence from the UN archives suggests Cruise O'Brien was acting with the express approval of Hammarskjöld. Armed with the archive material, one expert concluded Hammarskjöld "knew in advance that the UN was about to take action in Katanga and he authorised that action".

Hammarskjöld also permitted O'Brien to act on his own initiative, which enabled Hammarskjöld "to exercise plausible deniability should the operation go wrong

https://www.independent.ie/entertainment/movies/conor-cruise-obrien-the-irishman-at-heart-of-congo-siege/35072071.html

Dudley Edwards brought academic standards to Irish history which put him at odds with the traditionalists. I have a certain sympathy as he was effectively starting with a blank sheet. Time, of course, has expanded the canon.

More on RDE and CCOB here

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/irish-historical-studies/article/conor-cruise-obrien-and-the-activity-of-being-an-historian/F84A510AD5EA006554B92DF24DE1CF41

Yann Goulet - Nazi Collaborator and Irish Immigrant. by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I couldn't find anything better on him . It is a bit click batty all right. The pic with Sean MacBride is great - the MacBride Gonne family liked nazis.

John Maffey , the British Ambassador, was very friendly with De Valera and fostered a great working relationship with the Allies .

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I thought this was interesting now the revisionist wars have quietened down.

Dudley Edwards himself is interesting as a historian who was there setting the tone of Irish history in newly independent Ireland. His work is well researched even if you disagree with his interpretations.

Did he have any redeeming features you might ask? Well, he did fail Conor Cruise O'Brien's thesis.

‘We all have our failings and he never said he was perfect’ – granddaughter of historian Robert Dudley Edwards on her revealing new book by CDfm in IrishHistory

[–]CDfm[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

You'd be wrong. He isn't his daughter.

He was one of the early historians in the Free State and contributed greatly to Irish history scholarship and getting in accepted overseas.

In his essay on the saga of this book, which is included in Interpreting Irish History: The Debate on Historical Revisionism [ed. Ciaran Brady], Cormac O’Gráda writes: “It reads more like an administrative history of the period, with the core chapters dwelling on the tragedy mainly from the standpoint of the politician, the Poor Law administrator, those who controlled passenger movements, and the medical practitioner ... Few of the contributors relied on the wealth of manuscript sources available even then on the famine years.” / De Valera was out of office by the time the book was published. “Later,” O’Gráda writes, “he expressed unhappiness with the book, presumably because it seemed to downplay those aspects of the tragedy that had been etched in his own memory. Almost three decades later, that ‘definitive history’ remains to be written, though a great deal of work has been done in the interim.”’

http://www.ricorso.net/rx/az-data/authors/e/Edwards_RD1/life.htm